Wally and Olly’s Ice Cream

For residents of Kokomo, Indiana, and those exploring our vibrant community, Wally and Olly’s Ice Cream stands as a true local treasure. This charming, family-owned and operated ice cream shop is more than just a place to grab a cone; it's a destination that blends delicious frozen treats with a unique, nostalgic atmosphere. Since opening in March 2021, Wally and Olly's has quickly become a beloved fixture on the north side of town, earning a reputation for serving some of the best ice cream in Kokomo, and indeed, some of the best many customers have tasted in a long time. It's a place where every visit feels special, drawing in patrons with its warm hospitality and a menu designed to delight all ages.

What truly sets Wally and Olly’s apart is its commitment to offering a wide variety of beloved ice cream brands, ensuring there's something to satisfy every palate. They proudly serve popular names like Glover's, Deans, and Hundleston ice cream, providing a diverse selection of hard-dip flavors that keeps customers coming back to try new favorites. Many reviewers attest to the exceptional taste, with one exclaiming, "Honestly the best in Kokomo in my opinion, some of the best I’ve had in a long time!" This dedication to quality ice cream is a cornerstone of their appeal.

Beyond the impressive array of ice cream, Wally and Olly's extends its offerings to include a variety of concession-style foods, making it a convenient stop for a light meal or savory snack before diving into dessert. From pulled pork sandwiches and coney dogs to pretzels and nachos, their menu provides diverse options that complement their sweet treats perfectly. This versatility, combined with the shop's welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, ensures that Wally and Olly's is not just an ice cream shop, but a comprehensive local eatery that caters to the community's diverse needs and cravings.

Wally and Olly’s Ice Cream is conveniently located at 419 E Gano St, Kokomo, IN 46901, USA. This address places the beloved ice cream shop on the north side of Kokomo, making it easily accessible for residents in the area and those traveling from other parts of Indiana. East Gano Street is a part of Kokomo's local street grid, contributing to the shop's visibility and straightforward navigation.

A unique aspect of Wally and Olly's location is its picturesque setting by the Eel River. The shop is housed in a transformed old gas station, a small red brick building that was once an abandoned property, now beautifully repurposed. This transformation, along with outdoor seating and benches positioned to allow patrons to sit and enjoy their ice cream "amongst the river," adds a distinctive charm to the experience. The proprietors, Ron and Debra Toth, have infused the space with a historical ambiance, featuring "historical artifacts" and even a Ford Model A outside, evoking a "slower pace" reminiscent of the 1920s and 30s.

Accessibility to Wally and Olly's is generally convenient for those driving, with available parking nearby. The family-oriented nature of the business and its welcoming environment extend to its physical layout, aiming to be approachable for all visitors. The unique setting by the river, combined with the historical decorative elements, creates an inviting atmosphere that encourages lingering and enjoying the surroundings as much as the treats. This blend of accessibility and unique charm makes Wally and Olly's a prominent and beloved landmark in the Kokomo community.

Services Offered:

• Wide Range of Ice Cream Brands and Flavors: Wally and Olly's features popular ice cream brands such as Glover's, Deans, and Hundleston, offering a rotating selection of 20 hard-dip flavors at all times. This includes classic flavors in waffle and cake cones, sundaes, and milkshakes.
• Concession-Style Foods: In addition to ice cream, the shop offers a variety of savory options, including pulled pork sandwiches, pretzels, coney dogs, taco salad, and nachos.
• Other Frozen Treats: The menu extends beyond traditional ice cream to include snowcones and blasts, catering to diverse preferences for cold treats.
• Beverages: A selection of drinks is available to complement both the sweet and savory items on the menu.
• Seasonal Operation: Wally and Olly's typically operates seasonally, opening in the spring when the weather permits and closing the last week of October. During summer months, they plan to be open seven days a week, often extending hours until 10 p.m. on weekends.

Features / Highlights:

• Family-Owned and Operated: Wally and Olly's is a family-run business, named after two of the owners' grandchildren. This creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere where the whole family often helps out, fostering a strong connection with the community.
• Unique Nostalgic Atmosphere: The shop is set in a transformed old gas station by the Eel River, adorned with historical artifacts and a Ford Model A. This gives it a charming, "1920s and 30s" feel, described as a "time warp" by customers.
• High-Quality Ice Cream: Consistently praised by customers as having "the best in Kokomo" and "some of the best I’ve had in a long time," highlighting the quality of the ice cream served.
• Diverse Menu Beyond Ice Cream: The inclusion of concession-style savory foods like pulled pork sandwiches and coney dogs makes it a versatile spot for both meals and desserts.
• Excellent Customer Service: Reviewers often mention the "friendly staff" and the owners' engagement with customers on a "first-name basis," contributing to a welcoming and community-oriented experience.
• Scenic Location: The seating and benches by the Eel River provide a pleasant environment to enjoy treats, making the visit even more relaxing and enjoyable.

Contact Information:

Address: 419 E Gano St, Kokomo, IN 46901, USA

Phone: (765) 437-0287

Wally and Olly’s Ice Cream in Kokomo, Indiana, consistently receives rave reviews from its patrons, quickly establishing itself as a beloved local spot. Customers are quick to declare their ice cream "the best in Kokomo" and even "some of the best I’ve had in a long time," eagerly anticipating its seasonal opening each year. The quality of the ice cream itself, featuring popular brands like Glover's, Deans, and Hundleston, is a major draw, with a wide variety of flavors keeping things exciting. Beyond the delicious treats, the unique atmosphere is frequently highlighted; its transformation from an old gas station by the Eel River, adorned with historical artifacts and a Ford Model A, creates a charming, nostalgic "time warp" that adds to the overall experience. Reviewers also praise the friendly and welcoming staff, noting the family-oriented service where owners often interact directly with customers. The shop's convenient dual offering of both ice cream and concession-style foods like pulled pork sandwiches and nachos further enhances its appeal, making it a versatile and enjoyable destination for the entire family.

In conclusion, Wally and Olly’s Ice Cream at 419 E Gano St, Kokomo, IN 46901, USA, is an exceptionally suitable and highly recommended destination for locals throughout Indiana, especially those in and around the Kokomo area. Its core appeal lies in its commitment to serving "the best" ice cream, featuring a diverse range of popular brands and flavors that consistently delight customers.

Beyond the delicious treats, the unique, family-owned atmosphere, complete with nostalgic decor and a scenic location by the Eel River, transforms a simple ice cream run into a charming experience. The friendly staff and the option for savory concession-style foods further solidify its role as a versatile and welcoming community hub. For residents of Indiana seeking a high-quality, memorable, and family-friendly spot for ice cream and more, Wally and Olly’s Ice Cream stands out as a true local gem, cherished for its flavors and its unique contribution to the Kokomo community. We eagerly await its opening each season to enjoy its offerings!

Wally and Olly’s Ice Cream

419 E Gano St, Kokomo, IN 46901, USA