Wally's Ice Cream Parlor II

For residents of Monroe, New York, and the wider Orange County area, Wally's Ice Cream Parlor II at 846 NY-17M is more than just a place to grab a cone; it's a cherished local institution that embodies the nostalgic charm of a classic ice cream parlor. This beloved spot has earned a reputation for its warm, family-friendly ambiance, incredibly generous scoops, and a genuinely friendly staff who truly care about making every customer happy. It's the perfect destination for a sweet reward after a walk or bike ride on the Heritage Trail, or simply a delightful outing for families and friends seeking a taste of pure, unadulterated ice cream joy in the Hudson Valley.

The experience at Wally's Ice Cream Parlor II is consistently praised by its dedicated patrons, highlighting the very qualities that make it a local favorite. As one reviewer enthusiastically shared, "If you're biking or walking on the heritage trail, this ice cream shop is perfect, nice and rewarding! Such delicious options, cash only, and quick service! My ice cream sundae was soooooo good!" Another customer emphasized the human element, stating, "The people here are so nice and the scope is very generous. They actually care about people being happy getting ice cream." The staff's commitment to service shines through, with one patron noting, "Service is wonderful and especially the girl serving me with a big smile. Please support their college fund tipping jar." While a specific flavor might not appeal to everyone, as indicated by a comment about some flavors being "a bit too artificial," the overall sentiment remains overwhelmingly positive, with the "Peanut Butter Chip" flavor receiving special commendation. The overall "ambiance is very family friendly" and it feels "like an old school ice cream parlor should be and nothing fancy," making it an authentic and welcoming spot for all ages.

Wally's Ice Cream Parlor II is conveniently located at 846 NY-17M, Monroe, NY 10950. This strategic position on New York State Route 17M provides excellent accessibility for residents within Monroe and the surrounding communities in Orange County. Route 17M is a significant thoroughfare, ensuring high visibility and straightforward navigation for those traveling by car. A key highlight of its location, as noted by customers, is its proximity to the Heritage Trail, making it an ideal and "rewarding" stop for those enjoying outdoor activities like biking or walking. This makes it a natural gathering point for recreation enthusiasts seeking a refreshing treat.

The accessibility of Wally's extends well beyond Monroe's immediate borders. Route 17M connects to major regional arteries, including Route 17 (Future I-86) and Route 208, allowing for convenient travel from neighboring towns such as Chester, Central Valley, Highland Mills, and Washingtonville. This widespread connectivity ensures that a wide demographic from across Orange County can easily reach this beloved ice cream parlor. Ample parking is typically available at such roadside establishments, contributing to a hassle-free arrival and departure experience. The "nice location" combined with its easy accessibility makes Wally's Ice Cream Parlor II a prime and appealing destination for a classic ice cream experience in the Hudson Valley, perfectly catering to both local foot traffic and those arriving by vehicle.

Wally's Ice Cream Parlor II offers a classic ice cream parlor experience with a focus on generous portions and beloved favorites.

• Generous Ice Cream Scoops: Customers consistently praise the "generous scope" of their ice cream, ensuring a satisfying amount of deliciousness with every order.
• Delicious Ice Cream Options: The parlor offers a variety of "delicious options," catering to different preferences. While not all flavors are universally loved, classics and favorites like the "Peanut Butter Chip" receive high praise.
• Classic Ice Cream Sundaes: A highlight for many, their ice cream sundaes are noted as "soooooo good," suggesting a well-crafted traditional dessert with quality ingredients.
• Creamy Shakes (Implied): While not explicitly mentioned in the provided reviews, "ice cream parlor" ambiance typically includes creamy shakes as a staple offering.
• Kid-Sized Portions with Reasonable Prices: The availability of "kid sized with reasonable price" options makes it an excellent choice for families, ensuring children can enjoy a treat without breaking the bank.
• Cash Only Transactions: It's important for customers to note that this establishment operates on a "cash only" basis, ensuring quick and efficient transactions.
• Quick Service: Despite its popularity, customers commend the "quick service," ensuring that wait times are minimal, allowing for a smooth and enjoyable experience.

Wally's Ice Cream Parlor II is cherished by locals for several distinct features and highlights that contribute to its enduring popularity.

• Exceptional Customer Service: This is a major highlight, with staff described as "so nice" and genuinely "care about people being happy getting ice cream." The presence of a "big smile" and a "college fund tipping jar" further reinforces the friendly and community-oriented approach. The service consistently earns five stars.
• Generous Portions: The emphasis on "generous scope" means customers feel they are getting excellent value for their money, a significant draw for any local business.
• Family-Friendly Ambiance: The atmosphere is noted as "very family friendly," reminiscent of "an old school ice cream parlor." This nostalgic and welcoming environment makes it comfortable and enjoyable for all ages, without being overly "fancy."
• Proximity to Heritage Trail: Its location makes it a "perfect, nice and rewarding" stop for those biking or walking the Heritage Trail, integrating seamlessly with local recreational activities.
• Affordable Kid Options: Offering "kid sized with reasonable price" caters directly to families, making it an accessible and attractive option for parents.
• Delicious Core Offerings: Despite some specific flavor preferences, the overall ice cream and especially the sundaes are lauded for being "delicious" and "soooooo good," maintaining a high standard of taste.
• Cash Only Efficiency: While potentially inconvenient for some, the "cash only" policy contributes to "quick service," which is a positive for efficiency.

For current operating hours, specific flavor availability, or any other inquiries, please contact Wally's Ice Cream Parlor II using the information below.

Address: 846 NY-17M, Monroe, NY 10950, USA

Phone: (845) 782-5656

In conclusion, Wally's Ice Cream Parlor II is an exceptionally suitable and highly recommended destination for locals in Monroe, New York, and the wider Orange County region. Its position on NY-17M and direct access from the Heritage Trail make it incredibly convenient. The heart of its appeal lies in its "old school ice cream parlor" charm, coupled with genuinely "nice" and "generous" staff who prioritize customer happiness. Patrons consistently praise the "delicious options," especially the "soooooo good" sundaes and the beloved "Peanut Butter Chip" flavor, all offered at "reasonable prices" for even "kid sized" portions. Despite being "cash only," the "quick service" ensures a smooth and enjoyable experience. For families and individuals seeking generous scoops, a warm, family-friendly atmosphere, and service that truly cares, Wally's Ice Cream Parlor II is undoubtedly the top choice and a cherished part of the Monroe community.

Wally's Ice Cream Parlor II

846 NY-17M, Monroe, NY 10950, USA