Whit's Frozen Custard: A Westerville Classic for Ohio Locals

Whit's Frozen Custard Introduce

Whit's Frozen Custard is a name synonymous with sweet traditions in many Ohio communities, and the Westerville location is a prime example of its enduring appeal. More than just a dessert shop, it's a local institution where families and friends gather to enjoy a taste of summer, no matter the season. Unlike traditional ice cream, frozen custard is a denser, smoother, and richer treat made with cream, sugar, and egg yolk. This unique composition gives it a velvety texture that many find irresistible. The shop's commitment to quality is evident in every scoop, with a focus on fresh ingredients and a meticulous process that ensures every serving is as perfect as the last.

The core of the Whit's experience is its famous daily flavor. In addition to a classic vanilla and chocolate, the shop rotates a special "flavor of the day," keeping the menu fresh and exciting for loyal customers. This consistent variety, combined with its high-quality product, makes Whit's a destination rather than a quick stop. Whether you're a long-time resident or new to the area, a visit to Whit's is a rite of passage for anyone with a sweet tooth. The friendly and efficient service, even during peak hours, contributes to a positive and memorable experience that keeps people coming back year after year. It's a place where you can create lasting memories, from a simple treat with the kids to a late-night dessert run with friends.

The Whit's Frozen Custard location in Westerville is conveniently situated at 46 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA. This address places it right in the heart of the city's historic and vibrant downtown area. The shop is easily accessible from various parts of Westerville and the surrounding suburbs, making it a popular destination for locals. Its central location makes it an ideal stop after a day of shopping, a local event, or a walk through the beautiful Uptown Westerville district.

For those driving, there is typically street parking available along North State Street and nearby side streets, though it can get busy during peak hours. The walkable nature of the area also makes it a great spot for pedestrians. Its proximity to other local businesses and parks ensures that a visit to Whit's can be part of a larger outing, adding to its appeal as a community hub. The visibility and easy navigation to this location mean that finding your way to a delicious scoop of frozen custard is always a simple and pleasant journey.

Whit's Frozen Custard offers a delicious menu centered around its signature frozen custard, but with enough variety to satisfy any craving. Their services are designed to provide a perfect treat for every occasion.

Daily Flavor & Flavor of the Week: In addition to their classic vanilla and chocolate, they offer a new, exciting flavor every day and a special flavor of the week, ensuring a unique experience with every visit.
Handcrafted "Whitser" Blends: Their signature Whitser is a popular choice, blending creamy frozen custard with a variety of mix-ins like candies, fruits, and nuts. The "Buckeye Madness" Whitser, in particular, is a local favorite.
Sundaes and Cones: Customers can choose from a classic cone, a cup of custard, or one of their many delicious sundaes topped with hot fudge, caramel, and other delectable sauces.
Pints, Quarts, and Cakes: For those who want to take the joy home, Whit's offers their frozen custard in various sizes, including pints and quarts. They also create custom frozen custard cakes, perfect for birthdays and celebrations.
Friendly and Efficient Service: Even with long lines on warm days, the staff is known for their ability to serve customers quickly and with a smile, ensuring a pleasant experience for everyone.

What makes Whit's Frozen Custard stand out in the competitive dessert landscape are its unique features and the unwavering quality of its products. These highlights are what have made it a beloved staple for so many people in the Westerville area.

Premium Frozen Custard: Whit's is celebrated for its use of fresh ingredients, which results in a frozen custard that is noticeably richer, smoother, and creamier than traditional ice cream. This quality is the foundation of their success.
Consistent Variety: The rotating daily and weekly flavors keep the experience new and exciting. This encourages repeat visits from customers eager to try the latest creation. It also ensures there's always something to discover beyond the classics.
Generous Portions and Value: While some may consider the prices a "nice treat every once in a while," many customers feel the portions are generous for the price. The "mini" size, in particular, is often noted as being more than enough for a satisfying indulgence.
Community Hub: The location in Uptown Westerville makes Whit's a central gathering point. It’s a place where you'll often see families and friends socializing on the benches outside, making it more than just a shop, but a true part of the community fabric.
Reliable Quality: Reviews from long-term customers consistently praise the shop's quality and service, highlighting the consistent experience over many years, which is a testament to the brand's dedication.

For those wishing to contact or visit this location, here is the essential information:

Address: 46 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

Phone: (614) 568-8055

For the residents of Ohio, especially those in and around Westerville, Whit's Frozen Custard is a perfect local gem. Its dedication to quality, its rich and creamy product, and its delightful variety of flavors make it a reliable and enjoyable destination. It's a place where a simple dessert becomes a cherished ritual, a small moment of joy that brightens the day. Whether you're a parent rewarding your children, a student grabbing a quick treat, or someone simply looking for a rich, satisfying dessert, Whit's meets the need. The generous portions and the delightful atmosphere, coupled with the central location, make it an easy and rewarding choice.

In a world of chain restaurants and generic treats, Whit's Frozen Custard offers something unique: a sense of place and a commitment to a premium product. It's a spot that has embedded itself into the community, and for good reason. Its blend of classic appeal and exciting variety ensures that it will continue to be a local favorite for many years to come, solidifying its place as a quintessential Ohio dessert destination.

Whit's Frozen Custard Menu

Ice Cream Social Party Packs
Candy Craze US$35.00
Perfect for any candy lover. Your box will include: 2 Vanilla Quarts M&M’s butterfinger heath bar snickers 8 serving cups
Chocolate & Berries US$35.00
A perfect pack for any celebration! Your box will include: 2 Vanilla Quarts Blueberry Topping Strawberries Raspberry Topping Chocolate Flakes 8 serving cups
Buckeye Game Day US$35.00
Perfect for your Football Party! Contains 1 Quarts of Buckeye Custard 1 Quart of Vanilla Custard Reese's Cups Reese's Pieces Chocolate Syrup Peanut Butter 8 serving cups
Cookie Monster US$35.00
A favorite for any cookie lover. Your box will include: 1 Chocolate Quart 1 Vanilla Quart cookies & crème cookie dough bites chocolate flakes chocolate syrup 8 serving cups
Birthday Party! US$35.00
A perfect pack for a Birthday Party or any celebration! Your box will include: 1 Chocolate Quart 1 Vanilla Quart Sprinkles M&M’s gummy worms chocolate syrup 8 serving cups

Chocolate Bananas
Chocolate Dipped With Sprinkles US$5.50
Chocolate Dipped With Chopped Nuts US$5.75
Chocolate Dipped US$5.00
Chocolate Dipped With Krunch Kote US$5.50
Krunch Kote – A chocolate-dipped banana coated in Krunch Kote: a sweet, crunchy blend of peanuts, candy bits, and sprinkles. A fun mix of texture and flavor in every bite.

Dog Sundaes, Cones, Drinks and More!
Cones US$5.00
Add cones to go with your favorite Whit's!
Doggie Sundae / Pup Cup US$3.50
For your furry friend: vanilla custard with peanut butter and a dog bone
Whit's Italian Ice US$5.00
A single cup of Whit's Italian Ice which is gluten and dairy free, available in Cherry or Blue Raspberry flavor.
Whit's Bottled Soda US$3.50
Add a bottle of Whit's Orange Soda or Whit's Root Beer to your order!
Whit’s Pints US$9.00
Bottled Water US$2.50
Little Whit Plush Penguin US$20.00
Our favorite little mascot measures approximately 6.5 inch tall

Whit's Frozen Custard Quarts
Black Raspberry Chip Quart US$12.00
We blend our black raspberry custard with dark chocolate flakes. It's easy to see why this is one of our best selling flavors.
Chocolate Quart - POPULAR ITEM US$12.00
A quart of our dreamy chocolate custard
Almond Joy Quart US$12.00
Our take on the famous candy bar. It's our toasted coconut custard mixed with roasted almonds, dark chocolate flakes and toasted coconut.
Strawberry Quart US$12.00
A quart of our classic strawberry custard blended with real strawberries. Simple and delicious!
Red Velvet Cake Quart US$12.00
We mix real red velvet cake pieces and cream cheese frosting into our vanilla custard to create the perfect combination for all you red velvet cake lovers!
Mud Pie Quart US$12.00
We take our coffee flavored custard and mix it with cookies & creme pieces and add caramel swirls for a pefect coffee inspired treat!
Cookies 'N Creme Quart US$12.00
So simple yet so delicious. We mix cookies & creme pieces with our vanilla custard.
Buckeye Quart - CUSTOMER FAVORITE! US$12.00
One of our most popular flavors - our peanut butter custard mixed with Reese's peanut butter cups and peanut butter to create a perfect combo for game day or any special event!
Cookie Dough Quart US$12.00
Cookie dough lovers rejoice! We mix chocolate chip cookie dough bites into our famous vanilla custard and add a little chocolate syrup too!
Fluffer Nutter Quart US$12.00
If you love peanut butter & marshmallow together, this one is for you! We combine our creamy vanilla custard with peanut butter swirls and marshmallow topping.
Birthday Cake Quart US$12.00
A perfect flavor for all celebrations! We mix real cake pieces, buttercream frosting, cake mix and sprinkles with our vanilla custard. You can easily skip the cake and just serve this treat!
Mint Chocolate Chip Quart US$12.00
You'll easily see why this is a best seller - it's our mint flavored custard mixed with dark chocolate flakes.
Cookie Monster Quart US$12.00
A cookie lovers dream! We mix cookies & creme pieces, cookie dough bites and chocolate syrup into vanilla custard to create the any cookie monster's favorite frozen treat!
Butter Pecan Quart US$12.00
This one is a classic - its our butterscotch custard mixed with roasted pecan halves.
Penguin Tracks Quart US$12.00
We mix brownie bites, caramel and fudge into our classic vanilla custard. This one is Little Whit's favorite flavor!
Flavor Of The Week Quart US$12.00
Visit Whit's Westerville website to check out the weekly flavor calendar (please note our flavors of the week start on Monday's and end of Sundays): https://whitscustard.com/locations/westerville
Vanilla Quart - MOST LOVED! US$12.00
A quart of our famous rich & creamy vanilla custard. Great item for pairing with your cake, pie or soda!
Sea Salt Caramel Quart - OWNER'S PICK! US$12.00
This one is the owner's favorite. We blend caramel swirls into our caramel flavored custard and add a dash of sea salt.
Cannonball Crunch (CBJ Exclusive Flavor) US$12.00
Cannonball Crunch: Caramel custard loaded with chocolate-covered pretzels, smooth caramel swirls and creamy peanut butter. This Columbus Blue Jackets exclusive is the ultimate power play of sweet and salty flavors. A true game-changer in every bite!

Whitties: Frozen Cookie Sandwiches
Chocolate Chip Vanilla Whittie - BEST SELLER! US$7.50
2 store baked chocolate chip cookies filled with a generous scoop of Whit's vanilla custard then frozen to perfection! This is our most popular Whittie.
Peanut Butter Buckeye Whittie - CUSTOMER FAVORITE! US$7.50
2 store baked peanut butter cookies filled with a generous scoop of our popular buckeye custard. Perfect for a game day treat!
Birthday Cake Whittie US$7.50
A scoop of our famous vanilla custard between 2 birthday cake cookies.
S'Mores Whittie US$7.50
It's our version of the campfire classic - 2 store baked S'mores cookies filled with a generous scoop of Whit's vanilla custard then we add chocolate drizzle coating and freeze!
Oatmeal Raisin Whittie US$7.50
This classic whittie combines 2 store-baked oatmeal raisin cookies with a generous scoop of Whit's vanilla custard.
Surprise Me With Any Flavor Whittie US$7.50
We make a lot of different whitties flavors. We will surprise you with any whittie from our case - it could be something new and you will discover a new favorite!
Double Dark Chocolate Whittie US$7.50
2 store baked double dark chocolate chip cookies filled with a generous scoop of Whit's chocolate custard then frozen to perfection!
M&M Vanilla Whittie US$7.50
We take 2 specialty store-baked M&M cookies and fill with our creamy vanilla custard.
Sugar Sprinkle Whittie US$7.50
We take 2 store baked sugar cookies, fill with a generous scoop of Whit's vanilla custard then we roll in rainbow or seasonal sprinkles. Fun Item Alert!

Custard & Oreo Sandwiches
Custard Sandwich 6pk - GREAT GROUP TREAT! US$20.00
Perfect group treat for home of the office! A 6-pack container with your choice of 6 vanilla filled custard sandwiches or 3 chocolate filled/3 vanilla filled custard sandwiches.
Oreo Sandwich US$5.00
We take a scoop of our famous vanilla custard and sandwich it between 2 jumbo Oreo wafers, then we freeze to perfection!
Custard Sandwich US$5.00
Choose from chocolate or vanilla custard between 2 chocolate wafers then frozen to perfection!

Cakes & Pies
Cookies & Creme Custard Pie US$20.00
We fill a graham cracker pie crust with our creamy vanilla custard, then top it with whip cream, cookies & cream and chocolate syrup. Serves 6+ people. Pie may vary from image shown. Always keep frozen until ready to serve, then thaw 5-10 minutes before cutting.
Celebration Custard Pie US$20.00
We take a graham cracker pie crust and fill it with our vanilla frozen custard, then top it with M&M’s, colorful sprinkles, whipped cream and chocolate syrup drizzle.
Small Buckeye Madness Cake US$35.00
Our most popular cake - buckeye madness. We combine vanilla custard with fudge, peanut butter, Reese's cups, chocolate syrup and whipped cream. Our small cake feeds 6-8. Keep cake frozen then allow to thaw approximately 20 minutes prior to serving.
Buckeye Madness Custard Pie US$20.00
We fill a graham cracker pie crust with our creamy vanilla custard then top with whip cream, peanut butter, chopped Reece's cups and chocolate syrup (pie may vary from image shown). Serves 6+ people. Keep pie frozen until ready to serve, then thaw 5-10 minutes before cutting.
Large Buckeye Madness Cake US$45.00
Our most popular cake - buckeye madness. We combine vanilla custard with fudge, peanut butter, Reese's cups, chocolate syrup and whipped cream. Our large cake feeds 8-10+. Keep cake frozen then allow to thaw approximately 20 minutes prior to serving.
Mini Buckeye Madness Cake US$15.00
Meet our new newest cake offering… Mini cakes. This option serves 1-2 people for a small treat. It’s our vanilla custard with Reese’s cups, peanut butter, whipped cream and fudge.
Large Cookies & Creme Cake US$45.00
Our cookies & Creme cake consists of our 2 layers of our creamy vanilla custard, with cookies & creme pieces and fudge in the middle, then our cake is topped with whipped cream, more cookies and chocolate drizzle. Our large cake feeds 8-10+ people and should be kept frozen until ready to serve. Then, thaw for 15-20 minutes before cutting.
Small Cookies & Creme Cake US$35.00
Our cookies & Creme cake consists of our 2 layers of our creamy vanilla custard, with cookies & creme pieces and fudge in the middle, then our cake is topped with whipped cream, more cookies and chocolate drizzle. Our small cake feeds 6-8 people and should be kept frozen until ready to serve. Then, thaw for 15-20 minutes before cutting.

Dipped Drumsticks:❤️ Most Loved Item❤️
Chocolate Dipped US$9.00
Classic and satisfying: vanilla custard in a cone dipped in rich chocolate.
Chocolate Dipped With Nuts US$9.50
Chopped Nuts – Crunchy chopped nuts on rich chocolate over creamy vanilla custard.
Chocolate Dipped With Sprinkles US$9.25
Sprinkles – A fun twist with rainbow sprinkles over a chocolate-dipped vanilla cone.
Chocolate Dipped With M&M’s US$9.50
M&Ms– A waffle cone filled with frozen vanilla custard, dipped in chocolate and coated with colorful M&Ms. A perfect mix of smooth custard and sweet candy in every bite.

Whit's Frozen Custard Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Kerbside pickup
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
Takeaway
Dine-in

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park

Dining options
Table service

Amenities
Toilet

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Groups

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Whit's Frozen Custard Photos

Whit's Frozen Custard Location

Whit's Frozen Custard

Ohio Franklin County Westerville North State Street

46 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081, USA

Whit's Frozen Custard Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 365 user reviews.

flavorspricesice cream sandwicheswalkvanillasundaespieraspberryveganroot beer

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Whit’s is always a great option for ice cream on hot summer days. I usually get a mini Buckeye Madness “whitser”, which is their smallest size but still has enough ice cream for me. Their prices are a little expensive in my opinion but it still works great as a nice treat every once in a while.
June 30 · Kaleb Bryant
We LOVE Whit’s custard!!! They have a daily flavor & a flavor of the week. Their ice cream is huge and well priced. Even when the line is long I think they do a great job of moving quickly. Whit’s is what is getting me through the summer of being very pregnant! Highly recommend, we frequent here.
April 24 · Marissa Dumford
Tried Whit’s Frozen Custard in town for the first time and loved it! The Hawaiian Lu’au (Pineapple, Coconut, Banana, and Macadamia Nuts) was a tropical delight, and the Banana Split was just perfect. Both flavors tasted amazing. I’ll be back for more!
July 23 · Suzayn
Incredible vegan ice cream. Buckeye flavor is a 10/10. Will have to try all of them!
June 05 · Ella Holzhei
I only really go here because I have coupons but I should start going here more often! I love the idea of how they have daily, weekly, AND monthly flavors! It’s nice to see what you could get today and what you could get the other days! The ice cream is amazing and I highly recommend.
March 13 · tien vu