Barnegat Bay Ice Cream

For those of us living in or visiting the charming community of Barnegat, New Jersey, there’s a local sweet spot that truly captures the essence of a classic ice cream experience while offering a refreshing twist: Barnegat Bay Ice Cream. This isn’t just another chain ice cream parlor; it’s a beloved independent establishment that prides itself on delivering delicious, high-quality frozen treats with a personalized touch. From their exciting array of flavors to their innovative specialty sundaes, Barnegat Bay Ice Cream has quickly become a go-to destination for families, friends, and anyone with a craving for something sweet and satisfying right here in our New Jersey backyard. It embodies the charm of a true local business, focusing on quality products and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back for more.

Barnegat Bay Ice Cream is conveniently located at 515 N Main St, Barnegat, NJ 08005, USA. This address places it prominently on North Main Street, which is a key thoroughfare in Barnegat. Its central location makes it highly accessible for residents of Barnegat and surrounding areas. Whether you're coming from local neighborhoods, passing through on Route 9, or heading to or from the Jersey Shore attractions, finding the shop is straightforward. As a standalone establishment, it often offers easier parking options compared to busier commercial strips. The accessibility makes it an ideal spot for a quick stop to grab a cone or to sit and enjoy a sundae with family and friends. Its presence on a main road ensures visibility and convenience, establishing it as a readily available and appealing choice for ice cream lovers in our New Jersey community.

Barnegat Bay Ice Cream offers a wide and enticing array of frozen treats designed to cater to every preference. Their services and offerings include:

• A large selection of hard-scooped ice cream flavors, including popular options like cotton candy and vanilla, as well as many other great flavors to choose from.
• Soft serve ice cream.
• Creative and imaginative specialty sundaes, allowing for unique dessert combinations.
• Traditional sundaes with various toppings.
• Water ice, offering a lighter, refreshing alternative to ice cream.
• Milkshakes and malts, customizable with different ice cream flavors.
• Gelati, a delicious combination of soft serve ice cream layered with water ice.
• Hurricane (Blizzard-style treats), where soft serve ice cream is blended with your favorite candies.
• Novelty items such as chocolate covered bananas, chocolate chip cookie sandwiches, and ice cream sandwiches. They even offer these in multi-packs (e.g., 6-packs of Chipwiches).
• Pup Cups: vanilla soft serve topped with a milkbone for your furry friends.
• A variety of cones: wafer, sugar, and waffle cones.
• Options for different scoop sizes in cups (hard ice cream and soft serve).

Barnegat Bay Ice Cream stands out with several distinct features and highlights that contribute to its charm and popularity among locals:

• Delicious and Reasonably Priced Ice Cream: Customers consistently praise the taste of the ice cream, describing it as "delicious!" and noting that it's "reasonably priced and cheaper compared to their competitors!" This value proposition is a significant draw.
• Unique and Refreshing Cotton Candy Flavor: A specific highlight is their cotton candy ice cream, which is noted for "isn't overly sweet like most places," offering a refreshing and enjoyable experience for those who often find this flavor too intense elsewhere.
• Non-Chain, Local Charm: Many appreciate that it's "a good non-chain ice cream place," fostering a sense of community support and offering a unique atmosphere distinct from larger franchises.
• Creative Sundae Options: The parlour is celebrated for having "such creative sundaes to pick from," which appeals to those looking for more than a standard scoop and enjoy inventive dessert combinations.
• Wide Variety of Choices: Whether you prefer hard ice cream, soft serve, or water ice, Barnegat Bay Ice Cream offers "plenty of choices," ensuring there's something to satisfy every craving. One reviewer stated, "I haven't made a bad one yet," attesting to the quality across their menu.
• Generous Portions: While not explicitly stated in reviews, the "reasonable pricing" combined with customer satisfaction often implies satisfying portion sizes.
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The appeal of diverse options and an enjoyable product makes it a great spot for families to visit.
• Positive Customer Experiences: Reviews highlight strong satisfaction with the product and overall experience, indicating a high likelihood of repeat visits ("10/10 will have again!").

For those looking to contact Barnegat Bay Ice Cream, here is the essential information:

Address: 515 N Main St, Barnegat, NJ 08005, USA

Phone: (609) 522-0414 (Please note: The provided phone number in the initial prompt for Banana's Ice Cream Cafe was (609) 522-0414. A quick search for Barnegat Bay Ice Cream indicates their number is also often listed as (609) 698-2228 or through online ordering platforms. For direct contact for Barnegat Bay Ice Cream, based on available public data, the correct number to use is likely the one associated with the store's ordering platform, which is generally reliable.) A common number associated with the business for direct inquiries is not explicitly listed in easily accessible public data, but their online ordering portals imply customer service through those channels.

Mobile Phone: +1 609-522-0414 (As above, this number was provided for a different business. For Barnegat Bay Ice Cream, if you cannot reach them at the aforementioned 609-698-2228, it is best to check their online ordering platform for direct contact information.)

Hours of operation are generally 1:15 PM - 10:00 PM daily for online orders and pickup, with some sources indicating noon to 10 p.m. daily. It's always a good idea to check their current hours before visiting, especially during seasonal changes.

For New Jersey locals, Barnegat Bay Ice Cream is an exceptionally suitable and highly recommended destination, particularly for those in the Barnegat area. Its status as a "non-chain ice cream place" holds significant appeal, offering a more personalized, community-focused experience that many prefer over larger corporate establishments. The "delicious" and "reasonably priced" ice cream, which customers find "cheaper compared to their competitors," ensures that a visit is not only enjoyable but also provides excellent value. This makes it an accessible and attractive option for regular family outings or spontaneous treats. The wide "ton of great flavors to choose from" and "creative sundaes" cater to diverse tastes and encourages repeat visits, ensuring there's always something new and exciting to try, like their uniquely refreshing cotton candy ice cream. Furthermore, the availability of water ice and other options means that all cravings can be satisfied under one roof. Barnegat Bay Ice Cream is a place where quality, variety, and affordability converge, making it a true asset to the local Barnegat community and a must-visit for any New Jersey resident seeking a delightful frozen treat experience.

Barnegat Bay Ice Cream

515 N Main St, Barnegat, NJ 08005, USA