Frosty's Ice Cream

Welcome to Frosty's Ice Cream, a true Western New York institution that has been delighting locals and visitors in Lancaster for years. This seasonal ice cream shop isn't just a place to grab a cone; it's a community gathering spot and a summer tradition for many families. Situated in a distinctive building that was once a historic gasoline station, Frosty's has transformed into a beacon for anyone seeking a sweet treat. The atmosphere is always friendly and bustling, with a constant stream of customers drawn to its reputation for quality, variety, and famously large portion sizes. Many customers fondly recall visiting Frosty's since they were kids, a testament to its enduring appeal and consistent excellence. It’s a place where childhood memories are made and new ones are created every season.

What sets Frosty's apart is its commitment to both classic favorites and innovative new options. They proudly serve over 30 flavors of the locally-loved Perry’s hard ice cream, a staple in the WNY region. But the menu extends far beyond that. You can also find rich, creamy soft-serve custard, as well as a great selection of weekly rotating flavors and specialty items that keep people coming back for more. In an effort to cater to all dietary needs, Frosty’s has also expanded its offerings to include a decent vegan and dairy-free menu, featuring options like Dole soft serve, which is lactose-free, dairy-free, and gluten-free. For those with a more adventurous palate, they even experiment with unique creations, including weekly alcoholic ice cream flavors. Whether you're a purist who loves a simple scoop or an explorer looking for the next big thing in frozen desserts, Frosty’s delivers.

The experience of ordering at Frosty’s is simple and efficient, even during peak summer hours when lines can get long. You place your order at one window and then pick up your delicious treat from the next. The service is consistently great, with a team of friendly staff ready to help you navigate the extensive menu. While Frosty's prices are competitive with other local ice cream shops, the value is truly exceptional due to their legendary portion sizes. A single scoop here can feel like a double elsewhere, making every visit a worthwhile treat. It’s a place that delivers not just on flavor, but on generosity, ensuring that every customer leaves with a smile and a satisfyingly full cone.

As a seasonal business, Frosty's typically operates throughout the warmer months, becoming a regular summer destination for countless people in the Buffalo and Lancaster area. The anticipation of its opening each spring and the farewell until fall are regular events for its dedicated customer base. The love for Frosty's is a shared local experience, rooted in its quality products and the friendly, community-oriented atmosphere it has cultivated over the years.

The shop's commitment to community extends to its family-friendly features, including a play area right out front where kids can enjoy their treats while parents relax. It’s this combination of great food, great value, and a welcoming environment that has solidified Frosty’s status as a must-visit spot in Lancaster. So whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, a trip to Frosty's Ice Cream is a delicious way to experience a true piece of local culture.

Frosty's Ice Cream is conveniently located right on Broadway in Lancaster, making it a highly visible and easy-to-find destination. Its distinctive building ensures you can't miss it. The address is 5500 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086, USA. For those traveling by car, there is ample parking available. The shop's layout, with its dedicated ordering and pickup windows, is designed for a smooth customer experience, even when it's busy. The location is also easily accessible for local residents and those driving from nearby towns.

• Over 30 Flavors of Perry's Hard Ice Cream: A wide selection of flavors from a beloved local brand.

• Soft-Serve Custard: Real, old-fashioned soft custard, available in vanilla, chocolate, and twist, with a rotating flavor of the week.

• Specialty Sundaes and Parfaits: A huge variety of creative sundaes, including classics and unique signature items like the Warm Brownie Sundae and various parfaits.

• Milkshakes and Frozen Beverages: Over 80 milkshake flavors made with either hard ice cream or custard, plus floats, fruit fizzys, and more.

• Vegan and Dairy-Free Options: A dedicated menu featuring Dole Soft Serve, Italian ice, and specific Perry's flavors that cater to different dietary needs.

• Ice Cream Cakes: Custom-decorated ice cream cakes made with custard and crunchy fudge layers, available for all occasions.

• "Doggie Delights": A special treat just for your furry friends, ensuring the whole family can enjoy a visit.

• Legendary Portion Sizes: Frosty's is famous for its massive servings, with a large cone featuring a full pound of ice cream, often referred to as "the one-foot-tall cone."

• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The shop has a convenient play area in front, making it a great place for families with children to relax and enjoy their treats.

• Cash-Only Policy with On-Site ATM: To maintain efficiency, Frosty's operates on a cash-only basis, but an ATM is conveniently available on-site for customers.

• Unique and Rotating Flavors: The menu is constantly refreshed with weekly flavors and specialties, including seasonal items and creative alcoholic ice creams.

• Local Tradition: For over two decades, Frosty’s has been a family-owned and operated business, with a deep connection to the Lancaster community.

• Historic Building: The shop is housed in the former Liebler-Rohl Gasoline Station, a distinctive and locally recognized building that adds to its charm and character.

Address: 5500 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086, USA

Phone: (716) 697-1812

For anyone living in or around the New York region, especially in the Western New York area, Frosty's Ice Cream is more than just a dessert shop—it's a landmark and a seasonal rite of passage. It embodies the best of local business: a friendly, family-owned establishment that values tradition while also embracing creativity. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, the quality is top-notch, and the value is unbeatable, thanks to its famously generous portions. Whether you’re stopping by for a post-dinner treat with the kids, meeting up with friends, or simply satisfying a sweet craving, Frosty's offers a genuine and satisfying experience. It's a place where you'll likely see a neighbor or an old friend, and where every scoop is served with a bit of local charm. Its commitment to serving a wide variety of flavors, including options for those with dietary restrictions, ensures that there's truly something for everyone. This dedication to customer satisfaction and community makes Frosty's Ice Cream a perfect fit for locals who appreciate great food, great value, and a place that feels like home.

Frosty's Ice Cream

5500 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086, USA