A Local's Guide to Frozen Flavors in North Middletown, NJ

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Introduce

Hello, fellow New Jersey residents! When you're in the mood for a truly delicious frozen treat, there's nothing quite like a local spot that puts a personal touch on every scoop. In North Middletown, a beloved corner shop has captured the hearts of many with its commitment to homemade goodness: Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice. This isn't just a place to satisfy a sweet tooth; it’s a community gem where quality products and friendly service are at the heart of the experience. This article is your comprehensive guide to everything you need to know about Frozen Flavors, designed to help you, a local user, discover why it's a must-visit destination. We’ll delve into their diverse menu, convenient location, and the special features that make it a favorite for many.

Frozen Flavors has built a strong reputation by specializing in "premium handmade small-batch ice cream and Italian ice." This dedication to craftsmanship is a core part of their identity. Customers consistently praise the quality and taste of their offerings. One review from a satisfied customer who tried the frozen yogurt described the banana and blue raspberry flavors as "absolutely delicious" and noted they were "so impressed with both the service and the frozen yogurt selection." Another customer highlighted the "variety of flavors" and singled out the owner for being "enthusiastic to help me choose the right flavor" by offering samples of coconut-based options. The menu, as listed on various delivery apps, boasts an impressive array of over 25 flavors of homemade ice cream and an equally large list of small-batch Italian ice flavors. These include classics like Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry, as well as unique creations like "Samoa Cookie" and "Jersey Peach," showcasing their commitment to both traditional favorites and innovative new treats.

The atmosphere of the shop is also a major draw. Multiple reviews describe it as a "cute, little corner spot" that is well-kept and inviting. A customer noted, "the store looked so cute! ❤️" This pleasant environment, combined with the friendly and attentive service, makes for a great customer experience. While one customer wished for a bit more hot fudge and more cherries in their banana split, the overall positive feedback on the food and service underscores the shop's commitment to quality. The fact that the owner took the time to provide samples and help a customer find a flavor they would love is a perfect example of the kind of personalized service that makes a local business stand out. We'll explore all these elements to give you a clear picture of why Frozen Flavors is a valuable part of the North Middletown community.

Location and Accessibility

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice is located at 490 Palmer Ave, North Middletown, NJ 07748, USA. This address places it in a convenient "cute little corner spot" within the North Middletown community. Palmer Avenue is a well-traveled road, making the shop easily accessible for residents of Middletown and the surrounding towns. Its location makes it a great spot for a quick, casual treat, whether you’re driving by or heading there with friends and family.

The accessibility of this location is a key factor in its appeal. As a corner spot, it’s visible and easy to find, and there is generally convenient parking available nearby, which is a major plus for a quick trip. The shop’s presence in a quiet residential area gives it a neighborhood feel, making it a comfortable and familiar destination for locals. It's the kind of place you can easily stop at after dinner or on a weekend afternoon. The address, 490 Palmer Ave, is simple to plug into any GPS or mapping service, ensuring a straightforward and stress-free journey to this local gem. For locals in Monmouth County, it's a short and easy drive, cementing its status as a local favorite.

The shop's presence in this part of North Middletown contributes to the local flavor of the neighborhood, providing a dedicated space for people to enjoy high-quality desserts without having to travel far.

Services Offered

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice provides a wide array of services and products, living up to its name with a diverse and extensive menu. Their offerings are centered on their small-batch, homemade approach.

Homemade Hand-Dipped Ice Cream: Their primary service is serving handcrafted ice cream, made in small batches with premium ingredients. They have a variety of flavors, including classics like Vanilla and Chocolate, and unique ones such as Samoa Cookie, Jersey Peach, and Blueberry Cheesecake. A customer review mentions a favorite flavor was Almond Joy, showcasing the variety available.
Small-Batch Italian Ice: The shop also specializes in homemade Italian ice, with a large selection of flavors. Their offerings include traditional options like Cherry and Mango, as well as unique creations like Rocket Pop, Shirley Temple, and Churro. This dual focus on both ice cream and Italian ice gives customers a wide range of choices to suit their preferences.
Frozen Yogurt and Soft Serve: As mentioned in a customer review, they also offer "frozen yogurt selection" and "soft serve ice cream." The availability of these options provides a variety of textures and flavors beyond just hand-dipped ice cream, appealing to a wider audience.
Specialty Desserts: The menu also includes specialty items like milkshakes and banana splits. A customer review mentioned getting a banana split, and while they had minor feedback about the toppings, they appreciated the variety of flavors available for it. This shows their ability to create more elaborate desserts.
Take-Home Options: Customers can order their ice cream in pints and other to-go containers, perfect for enjoying at home or bringing to a gathering. This is a convenient option for locals who want to stock up on their favorite flavors.
Delivery and Pickup: Frozen Flavors offers online ordering and delivery through various third-party apps like Postmates, DoorDash, and Uber Eats. This modern convenience makes their delicious treats accessible to people who prefer to stay home.

Features and Highlights

What makes Frozen Flavors a top choice for locals in North Middletown? Several key features and highlights contribute to its positive reputation.

Homemade, Small-Batch Products: The commitment to making both their ice cream and Italian ice in "small-batches" with "premium ingredients" is a significant highlight. This ensures a high-quality product that tastes fresh and delicious, setting them apart from places that use pre-made mixes.
Extensive and Creative Flavor Menu: With dozens of flavors of both ice cream and Italian ice, the menu is a major draw. The variety includes both classic favorites and unique, innovative flavors, catering to all tastes. The availability of frozen yogurt and soft serve further expands the options for customers.
Friendly and Personal Service: Customer reviews highlight the friendly and attentive service. One reviewer praised the owner for taking the time to offer "samples of other flavors that were coconut based" after learning the customer liked coconut. This personalized, customer-focused approach makes for a positive and welcoming experience.
Charming and Clean Atmosphere: Multiple reviews describe the store as "cute" and a "cute little corner spot." This inviting atmosphere, combined with a clean and well-kept interior, makes it a pleasant place to visit and enjoy a treat.
Local and Family Operated: Frozen Flavors identifies itself as a "local and family operated business." This resonates with locals who appreciate supporting small businesses that are an integral part of their community. The store has two locations, in North Middletown and Union Beach, further solidifying its local roots.

Contact Information

To plan your visit or get in touch with Frozen Flavors, here is the essential contact information for the North Middletown location:

Address: 490 Palmer Ave, North Middletown, NJ 07748, USA
Phone: (848) 256-8266

You can call the phone number to inquire about their daily specials or hours of operation. The address is reliable for use with any GPS to get directions to the shop.

Conclusion: Why This Place is Suitable for Locals

For residents of North Middletown and the New Jersey region, Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice is an ideal local destination. It’s a classic local spot that has been praised for its high-quality, small-batch, homemade products. The vast selection of ice cream and Italian ice flavors ensures that there is a treat for everyone, from traditionalists to those seeking something new and exciting. The personal and friendly service, as highlighted in customer reviews, creates a welcoming and community-oriented atmosphere that makes every visit a pleasant one. The shop’s charming "cute little corner spot" feel adds to its appeal, making it a comfortable place for families and friends to gather. The fact that it is a local and family-operated business also makes it a great way for residents to support their community. For any local seeking a delicious, high-quality, and personalized dessert experience, Frozen Flavors is a highly suitable and recommended choice.

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Food & drink

Toppings - Go bigger YaY!!
Toppings - Cup $4.79
Cup toppings including various sprinkles, candies, cookies, and nuts. Serving size is 3.5 oz.

Your Way Banana Split
Banana Split - Soft Serve $12.90
Soft-serve ice cream. Two toppings of your choice. Homemade whipped cream and one cherry. NO SUBSTITUTES.
Classic Banana Split (Homemade) $12.90
One scoop of chocolate, vanilla & strawberry small batch homemade ice cream topped with homemade whipped cream with chocolate syrup, strawberry syrup, crushed pineapple and a cherry. NO SUBSTITUTES.
Banana Split - Homemade $12.90
Choice of ONE flavor small batch homemade ice cream. Two toppings of your choice, homemade whipped cream & cherry. NO SUBSTITUTES.

Novelty Sandwiches
Chocolate Chip Sandwich $7.96
Two chocolate chip cookies hugging your favorite ice cream flavor. Toppings available for extra fun!
Chocolate Chip Mini Bites $10.69
Dive into four mini ice cream sandwiches handmade with our chocolate and vanilla ice cream hugged by soft, chewy chocolate chip cookies. Snack time just got a lot more fun!
Oreo Cookie Sandwich $7.96
Two giant Oreo cookies hugging your favorite homemade ice cream flavor. Toppings available for extra fun!

Arctic Swirl
Arctic Swirl $8.75
Flavor choice soft serve with one mix-in topping. Add as many toppings as you want for an additional charge.

Novelty Cones - Homemade Sugar Cones
Fiesta Sugar Cone $1.86
Sugar Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Rainbow Sprinkles.
Plain Sugar Cone $1.56
Plain Sugar Cone.
Crunch Sugar Cone $1.86
Sugar Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Oreo crumbs.
Valentine's Sugar Cone $1.56
Sugar Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with red, white & pink Sprinkles
Coco Loco Sugar Cone $1.56
Sugar Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Coconut Flakes.
Chocolate Dipped Sugar Cone $1.86
Sugar Cone dipped in Chocolate.
Peppermint Sugar Cone $1.56
Sugar Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Crush Peppermint Candy.
Choc. Sprinkles Sugar Cone $1.56
Sugar Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Chocolate Sprinkles.
Crazy Nutz Sugar Cone $1.86
Sugar Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Crushed Peanuts.

Beverages
Bottled Water $2.00

Sundaes
Sundae - Homemade $10.20
Your own Sundae Creation, how cool is that!!. Made with our Homemade Small-Batch Ice Cream of your choice, ONE flavor. Includes one topping, topped off with Homemade whipped cream and a cherry. Additional toppings available for an exceptional mouth-watering experience. The combinations are endless!
Sundae - Soft Serve $10.20
Your own Sundae Creation, how cool is that!!. Made with our Creamy Dreamy Soft-Serve Ice Cream of your choice. Includes one topping topped off with Homemade whipped cream and a cherry. Additional toppings available for an exceptional mouth-watering experience. The combinations are endless!

Gelati
Gelati $8.95
Homemade Italian ice.

Homemade Italian Ice
Passion Fruit Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian Ice.
Root Beer Italian Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian ice.
Green Apple Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian ice.
Coconut Italian Ice $6.50
Experience the delightful essence of coconut with our homemade Italian ice.
Mango Italian Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian ice.
Horchata - New Flavor! $6.50
Iced Coffee Italian Ice $6.50
Rich, creamy coffee flavor blended into smooth, refreshing Italian ice. Coffee lovers favorite.
Shirley Temple Ice $6.50
Our homemade Shirley Temple Italian ice a delicious blend of grenadine, some lemon-lime soda, cherry juice and the main ingredient … Frozen Flavors super secret touch!
Rocket Pop Ice $6.50
Homemade Rocket Pop is the perfect explosive blend of the iconic red, white and blue flavors, all together in one totally awesome and refreshing combination!!
Piña Colada Italian Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian ice.
Cherry Italian Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian ice.
Churro Italian Ice $6.50
This crazy-delicious brown sugar & cinnamon blend delivers a taste you’ll love 💕 with notes of caramel, vanilla and graham flavors, all brought together with the warm and cozy Frozen Flavors touch
Orange Cream Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian ice.
Tiger's Blood Ice $6.50
Blue Hawaiian Italian Ice $6.50
Dive into a wave of tropical blue bliss with our Blue Hawaiian Italian Ice.
Rainbow Italian Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian ice.
Blue Raspberry Italian Ice $6.50
Bright blue raspberry delight in homemade Italian ice!
Sweetie Fish Italian Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian Ice
Chocolate Italian Ice $6.50
Rich chocolatey delight in every scoop!
Mint Chip Italian Ice $6.50
Homemade Mint Chocolate Chip Italian Ice is minty, smooth, sweet, and chocolaty all at once! This flavor is everything you’ve been craving for..
Pink Lemonade Ice $6.50
Lemon Italian Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian ice.
Bubblegum Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian ice.
Cotton Candy Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian ice.
Margarita Italian Ice $6.50
Homemade Italian ice.
Cherry Limeade Ice $6.50
The perfect blend of fruity, tart Cherry and Lime flavors, combined with a smooth, refreshing texture, makes this a truly special treat!

Homemade Ice Cream Pies
Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie $35.00
Homemade Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream layered over a made from scratch pie crust, topped off with our homemade icing and just enough ginger snaps crumbs drizzled with caramel
Strawberry Pie $33.00
Homemade Strawberry Ice Cream layered over a made from scratch pie crust, topped off with our homemade icing and decorated with chocolate covered fresh strawberries.
Gingersnaps Pie $33.00
Homemade Gingersnaps Ice Cream layered over a made from scratch pie crust, topped off with our homemade icing and just enough ginger snaps crumbs.
Peppermint Pie $33.00
Homemade Peppermint Ice Cream layered over a made from scratch pie crust, topped off with our homemade icing and just enough crushed peppermint candy sticks.
Banana Pie $33.00
Homemade Banana Ice Cream layered over a made from scratch pie crust, topped off with our homemade icing and just enough banana chip crumbs drizzled with caramel sauce.
Apple Caramel Pie $33.00
Homemade Apple Caramel Ice Cream layered over a made from scratch pie crust, topped off with our homemade icing decorated with apples and drizzle with caramel sauce.
Eggnog Pie $33.00
Homemade Eggnog Ice Cream layered over a made from scratch pie crust, topped off with our homemade icing and just enough ginger snaps crumbs.

Cakes
Valentine's Cake $39.99
6" Heart-shaped ice cream cake. This homemade ice cream cake is hand packed, chocolate and vanilla ice cream flavors with chocolate crunch in the middle.

Homemade Ice Cream
Black Raspberry $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Coconut Ice Cream $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Blueberry Cheesecake $7.50
Homemade Blueberry Cheesecake ice cream comes loaded with sweet blueberry swirls, crunchy pieces of graham crackers and the slight tartness of cheesecake.
Salted Caramel $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Eggnog Pie $6.50
Eggnog Pie is smooth, creamy and filled with the warm spices of the holiday season with lots of crunchy graham cracker pie crust pieces, this flavor is the perfect fireside frozen treat ‼️
Vanilla P. B. $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Cherry Vanilla $7.50
Key Lime Pie - NEW FLAVOR!! $7.50
Savannah Sunset - New Flavor! $7.50
Homemade Savannah Sunset Ice Cream, is another level of celebration just on time for Spring! Is vanilla base ice cream filled with sunset colored sprinkles and lots of mini animal crackers throughout. Inspired by the Lion King Jr. a MAC children's theater academy production sponsored by Frozen Flavors :)
Cookies 'N Cream $11.85
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Peppermint Candy Cane $7.00
Small batch homemade ice cream. Peppermint candy Cane is filled with crushed candy canes throughout. This flavor is refreshing holiday classic. Limited Edition.
Coffee Ice Cream $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Buddy's Mix (Elf Movie Inspired) $7.50
Buddy's Mix is all you've been waiting for the Holidays!! Your favorite toppings in one mouth-watering vanilla base ice cream. Chocolate chips, alphabet sprinkles and mini marshmallows.
Caramel Apple $11.85
Homemade Caramel Apple ice cream is a creamy delight filled with loads of bite sized pieces of apple and gooey caramel.
Dulce De Leche $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream
Mango Ice Cream - Last Call ! $7.50
Small batch homemade ice cream.
Almond Joy $7.50
Jersey Peach - NEW FLAVOR!! $7.50
Chocolate P.B. $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Strawberry Cheesecake $7.50
Small batch homemade ice cream.
Chocolate Ice Cream $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Apple Pie $11.85
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Choc.Fudge Brownie $7.50
Small-Batch Homemade Chocolate Ice Cream filled with brownie pieces and chocolate fudge swirls.
Banana $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Butter Pecan $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Cotton Candy Ice Cream $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Birthday Cake $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Mint Chip Ice Cream $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Mint Oreo $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Strawberry Banana $11.85
Strawberry Banana is made with fresh bananas and loads of homemade strawberry jam swirls. The perfect combination for a refreshing frozen treat!
Maple Walnut $11.85
Pistachio Nutz $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Orange Creamsicle - NEW FLAVOR!! $7.50
Strawberry $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Pumpkin Pie $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Samoa Cookie $7.50
Indulge in swirls of decadent caramel, chocolate fudge, toasted coconut flakes and loads of bite-sized pieces of Samoa cookies with our homemade Samoa Cookie Ice Cream . This flavor is inspired by the Samoa Girl Scout Cookie.
Watermelon - Seasonal $7.50
Cookie Dough $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Vanilla Chip $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.
Gingerbread $11.85
Gingerbread ice cream combines the best flavors of the season! deep notes of brown sugar, warm spices and of course chunks of gingerbread cookies add a delightful crunch, making each bite a perfect holiday treat!
Vanilla Homemade $7.50
Homemade hand-dipped ice cream.

Jordini
Jordini $8.90
Refreshing blend of your favorite homemade Italian Ice with vanilla mix cream.

Milkshakes
Milkshake - Soft Serve $9.86
Soft-Serve Ice Cream topped with homemade whipped cream & cherry.
BOGO Homemade Shake $9.86
Buy ONE get One of the SAME flavor of our homemade Ice Cream Shakes. Flavors listed below only. Limited time offer. NO SUBSTITUTES.
Milkshake - Homemade $9.86
ONE flavor of homemade Ice Cream topped with homemade whipped cream & cherry. NO SUBSTITUTES.

Ice Cream Sandwiches
Fiesta Sandwiches $20.90
Homemade sandwiches made with our creamy dreamy soft-serve ice cream, rolled in rainbow sprinkles and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. No substitutes. Pack of 6.
Swirly Twirly $20.90
Homemade sandwiches made with our creamy dreamy Vanilla & Chocolate Swirl soft-serve ice cream and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. No substitutes. Pack of 6.
Crazy Nutz $20.90
Homemade sandwiches made with our creamy dreamy soft-serve ice cream, rolled in peanuts and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. No substitutes. Pack of 6.
Halloween Sandwiches $20.90
Homemade sandwiches made with our creamy dreamy soft-serve ice cream, rolled in festive Halloween sprinkles and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. No substitutes. Pack of 6.
Chocolate Sprinkles $20.90
Homemade sandwiches made with our creamy dreamy soft-serve ice cream, rolled in chocolate sprinkles and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. No substitutes. Pack of 6.
Black & White $20.90
Homemade sandwiches made with our creamy dreamy Vanilla & Chocolate Swirl soft-serve ice cream and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. No substitutes. Pack of 6.
Chocolate Crunch $20.90
Homemade sandwiches made with our creamy dreamy soft-serve ice cream, rolled in chocolate crunch and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. No substitutes. Pack of 6.
Vanilla Sandwiches $20.90
Homemade sandwiches made with our creamy dreamy Vanilla soft-serve ice cream and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. No substitutes. Pack of 6.
Chocolate Sandwiches $20.90
Homemade sandwiches made with our creamy dreamy Chocolate soft-serve ice cream and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. No substitutes. Pack of 6.
Valentine - Limited Time $20.90
Homemade sandwiches made with our creamy dreamy soft-serve ice cream, rolled in festive Valentine sprinkles and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. No substitutes. Pack of 6.
Spring Celebration $20.90
Homemade sandwiches made in house with our creamy dreamy vanilla flavor soft-serve ice cream, rolled in spring festive sprinkles and sandwiched between two chocolate wafers. Pack of 6.

Bubble Waffle & Ice Cream
Naked Bubble Waffle - NEW !! $7.49
Bubble Waffle - Homemade $12.85
Bubble waffles and Ice cream! Take our homemade ice cream a notch up with our freshly made Bubble Waffles. They are crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. The ultimate frozen flavors experience that will leave you craving even more! Pick your favorite ice cream flavor, topping and a drizzle. * Freshly made to order and delivered separate for maximum crispness.
Bubble Waffle - Soft Serve $12.85
Bubble waffles and Ice cream! Take our Creamy Dreamy Soft Serve ice cream a notch up with our freshly made Bubble Waffles. They are crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. The ultimate frozen flavors experience that will leave you craving even more! Pick your favorite ice cream flavor, topping and a drizzle. * Freshly made to order and delivered separate for maximum crispness.

Novelty Cones - Homemade Waffle Cones
Fiesta Waffle Cone $1.96
Waffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Rainbow Sprinkles.
Coco Loco Waffle Cone $1.96
Waffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Coconut Flakes.
Choc. Sprinkles Waffle Cone $1.96
Waffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Chocolate Sprinkles.
Valentine's Waffle Cone $1.96
Waffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with red, white & pink Sprinkles
Crunch Waffle Cone $1.96
Waffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Oreo crumbs.
Plain Waffle Cone $1.96
Plain Waffle Cone
Chocolate Dipped Waffle Cone $1.96
Waffle Cone dipped in Chocolate.
Peppermint Waffle Cone $1.96
Waffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Crush Peppermint Candy.
Crazy Nutz Waffle Cone $1.96
Waffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with Crushed Peanuts.

Pint Bundle Package
All Pints $40.00
Stock up now on your favorite Frozen Flavors and never run out. Mix and Match any 4 pints of our homemade ice cream. Limited time offer.

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Onsite services
Takeout

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom

Dining options
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Photos

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Picture 1

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Picture 2

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Picture 3

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Picture 4

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Picture 5

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Picture 6

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Picture 7

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Picture 8

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Picture 9

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Location

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice

New Jersey Monmouth County Middletown Township North Middletown Palmer Avenue

490 Palmer Ave, North Middletown, NJ 07748, USA

Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 184 user reviews.

pricebananaselectionmilkshakeconecupso deliciouscashareashirley temple

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

My sisters and I stopped by the store and were so impressed with both the service and the frozen yogurt selection! The banana and blue raspberry flavors were absolutely delicious. We’re already planning to come back soon to try the soft serve ice cream next! Also, I have to say — the store looked so cute! ❤️
May 20 · Amelíe
I got the banana split with almond joy ice cream. I love the variety of flavors and the owner seemed enthusiastic to help me choose the right flavor. I told him originally I liked coconut, he took the time to pass me samples of other flavors that were coconut based. Cute little corner spot for ice cream. I just wish they added a bit more hot fudge sauce to the split and maybe a couple more cherries. 😋
July 12 · Helen Rotondo
This was my first visit to this ice cream shop, and I was thoroughly impressed. They offer a wide variety of flavors to choose from, making it easy to find something for everyone. My daughter went with a classic combination of vanilla and chocolate, while I tried the mint Oreo and cherry vanilla. Every flavor was rich, creamy, and full of taste — you can tell they use quality ingredients. We both enjoyed our treats immensely. On top of that, the service was outstanding — friendly, efficient, and welcoming. We’ll definitely be coming back!
July 12 · Sonia Laul
Our first time here. The ice cream was delicious. I enjoyed the bubble waffle. We did get a frozen root beer, I forget what it was called but everything was delicious.
May 14 · Mary Robinson
Very friendly place. The moment I walk in, I was greeted nicely. I had an idea of what to get and told him the flavors I like. He let me try some of my favorite flavors and I love the key-lime pie. It has gram crackers which offer a nice texture to the creaminess of the ice cream. Will definitely come here after spending time at the beach!
June 23 · Tiffany Anele