Gelateria Gentile on Amsterdam Ave: A Taste of Italy on the Upper West Side

Gelateria Gentile Introduce

In the heart of the Upper West Side, where bustling streets meet a vibrant local community, a true gem of Italian confectionery has established itself: Gelateria Gentile. Located at 498 Amsterdam Avenue, this charming cafe offers more than just a sweet treat; it provides an authentic Italian experience. For local residents and visitors alike, Gelateria Gentile has become a must-visit destination for those with a refined palate and a love for high-quality desserts. The store’s rich history, dating back to 1880 in Southern Italy, is a testament to its commitment to traditional recipes and passion for quality, which is evident in every scoop of creamy gelato and every delicate pastry.

The atmosphere inside Gelateria Gentile is as inviting as its menu. Customer reviews frequently highlight the "warm and inviting" ambiance, with "tasteful decor and well-arranged tables." It's the kind of place where you can comfortably sit, relax, and enjoy the beautiful street view, watching the world go by. This cozy setting is complemented by the pleasant background music, with one reviewer noting that whoever "picked the musics has good taste too." This attention to detail in creating a welcoming environment makes a visit here a truly special occasion, whether you're grabbing a quick treat or settling in for a leisurely afternoon with friends or family. The overall feel is one of a European cafe, providing a small, delightful escape from the daily grind of New York City life.

While the atmosphere is a significant draw, the true star of Gelateria Gentile is, of course, the gelato. The store's commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients results in a product that is praised for being "incredibly creamy, rich in flavor, and a delightful treat." A specific customer review called out the "Tartufo Pistachio" as "absolutely delicious," a decadent dessert combining rich pistachio and stracciatella gelato coated in a pistachio glaze. This level of praise for a specific item speaks volumes about the quality and care that goes into each of their creations. From classic flavors to more unique options and vegan sorbetto, there's always something new to discover, keeping loyal customers coming back for more.

Gelateria Gentile is perfectly situated at 498 Amsterdam Avenue, New York, NY 10024, USA, in the heart of the Upper West Side. This prime location places it within easy walking distance of countless residential buildings, local shops, and cultural institutions, including Central Park, which is just a few blocks away. For those who rely on public transportation, the store is highly accessible. It's a short walk from the 1, 2, and 3 subway lines, as well as several major bus routes that run along Amsterdam Avenue and Broadway. This convenience makes it a simple stop for residents on their daily commute, a perfect place to refuel after a walk in the park, or a destination for an evening dessert.

The foot traffic on Amsterdam Avenue is a constant, and Gelateria Gentile is ideally positioned to catch the eye of passersby. Its storefront is welcoming and its reputation, as noted by locals who believe it's "the best in the area," makes it a beacon for gelato enthusiasts. The store’s location within a charming and safe neighborhood adds to its appeal, making it a comfortable place to visit at any time of day. This strong community presence and easy accessibility are key factors in its success and its suitability for the Upper West Side lifestyle, where a great cafe is not just a place to eat, but a place to gather and feel at home.

Gelateria Gentile offers a variety of services and products that extend beyond just gelato, creating a comprehensive Italian cafe experience.

Services Offered:

Authentic Gelato: The star attraction. They offer a wide range of creamy, high-quality gelato flavors, including classic cups, cones, and specialty desserts like the Tartufo Pistachio. Vegan sorbetti options are also available for those with dietary restrictions.
Fine Italian Pastries and Desserts: The menu features a curated selection of other Italian sweets, such as pastries, cakes (like Torta Nera), and a delightful array of semifreddi like Tiramisu'.
Coffee and Espresso Bar: For those who appreciate a classic Italian caffè experience, they serve a variety of coffee and espresso-based drinks, perfect for pairing with a pastry or gelato.
Take-Home Gelato: Customers can purchase gelato in pints and quarts, allowing them to bring the delicious taste of Italy home to share with family and friends.
Delivery Services: The store partners with popular delivery services like DoorDash and Grubhub, making it possible for locals to enjoy their favorite desserts from the comfort of their own homes.

This diverse offering ensures that whether you're looking for a quick treat or a full dessert experience, Gelateria Gentile has something to satisfy your craving.

Features / Highlights:

Incredibly Creamy and Flavorful Gelato: The quality of the gelato is a consistent highlight, with reviews praising its creamy texture and rich, authentic Italian flavors.
Charming and Cozy Atmosphere: The "warm and inviting" decor and the great view of the street create a comfortable and relaxing environment, perfect for a leisurely visit.
Unique Specialty Desserts: The availability of products like the Tartufo Pistachio and other traditional Italian pastries sets Gelateria Gentile apart from a typical ice cream shop, offering a more gourmet experience.
High-Quality Ingredients: The store's use of fresh, high-quality ingredients, from their gelato to their pastries, is a defining feature that customers appreciate and can taste in every bite.
Excellent Location and Accessibility: Situated on a prominent avenue in a popular neighborhood, the store is easy to get to, whether by foot or public transit, making it a convenient stop for a wide range of people.

These highlights, as noted in customer reviews, are what make Gelateria Gentile a beloved part of the Upper West Side community.

For those ready to visit this charming cafe or with any questions, here is the contact information.

Contact Information:

Address: 498 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA
Phone: (646) 398-7171
Mobile Phone: +1 646-398-7171

Feel free to call them to inquire about their daily flavor selection or for any other information you may need before your visit.

In conclusion, Gelateria Gentile is more than just a dessert shop; it’s an authentic slice of Italy right in the heart of New York City. The combination of incredibly creamy gelato, an array of fine Italian pastries, and a warm, inviting atmosphere makes it perfectly suited for locals on the Upper West Side. It's a place where you can find a moment of peace and indulgence, whether you're enjoying a gelato while watching the world go by or catching up with a friend over coffee and a pastry. The store’s commitment to quality and tradition, as evidenced by its delicious products, resonates with a community that appreciates fine craftsmanship. For anyone living or working in the area, Gelateria Gentile offers a reliable, high-quality destination for a sweet treat that feels both special and comfortably local, solidifying its place as a true neighborhood favorite.

Gelateria Gentile Menu

Gelato (Online) - Gelato (Online)
Gelato Pint $20.00
Choose 1 or 2 of our top gelato or vegan sorbet flavors. Creamy, fresh, and made with the best ingredients for an authentic Italian treat!
Gelato Quart $40.00
Choose 1 to 3 of our top gelato or vegan sorbet flavors. Creamy, fresh, and made with the best ingredients for an authentic Italian treat!
Baby Cones (10 Pieces) $3.00
Mini crispy cones, perfect for creating bite-sized gelato treats at home with your favorite pint or quart
Frappe' (Italian Milkshake) $8.50
A rich and creamy blended drink made with our artisanal gelato and fresh milk for a perfectly smooth texture
Panna Pint (Fresh Whipped Cream) $21.00
Light, airy, and made fresh daily for the perfect finishing touch to any dessert
Panna Quart (Fresh Whipped Cream) $42.00
Light, airy, and made fresh daily for the perfect finishing touch to any dessert
Wafer Cone $0.75
Light, crispy, and delicately sweet, perfect for enjoying your gelato cones with your favorite pint or quart
Home Made Empty Cone $1.00
Our light, crispy homemade cone, perfect to pair with your favorite pint or quart

Gelato (Online) - Dessert/Semifreddi (Online)
Tiramisu' $10.00
Classic Italian dessert served in a ready-to-enjoy cup. Made with the traditional recipe for a perfect balance of creamy mascarpone, espresso-soaked ladyfingers, and a dusting of cocoa
Tartufo Al Caffe' $9.00
A ready-to-enjoy dessert with Coffee and Milk cream gelato, finished with a rich Nutella glaze
Tartufo Al Pistacchio $9.00
A ready-to-enjoy dessert with Pistachio and Stracciatella gelato, coated in a rich pistachio glaze
Cassata Cake $9.00
A slice of cassata cake with Crema Antica and Chocolate gelato, sour cherries, sponge cake soaked in Strega liqueur, and cassata semifreddo with chocolate chips, candied fruits, and nuts
Torta Croccante $55.00
A dessert with an almond biscuit base, Valrhona Ivoire (35%) white chocolate mousse, Milk cream gelato, Macadamia nuts, and sour cherries. A frozen dessert, perfect to keep in your freezer and enjoy anytime
Torta Classica $55.00
A dessert with an almond biscuit base, Crema Antica mousse (vanilla with lemon zest), coffee gelato, and a crunchy coffee topping. A frozen dessert, perfect to keep in your freezer
Torta Leggera (Lactose-Free) $55.00
A lactose-free dessert with an almond biscuit base, Bourbon vanilla mousse, raspberry cremoso, and a pistachio crunch. Perfect to enjoy from the fridge or freezer.
Torta Straordinaria $60.00
A dessert with Gianduja chocolate mousse, chocolate biscuit, Valrhona Jivara (40%) milk chocolate mousse, butter salted caramel, and macadamia nuts. Perfect to enjoy from the fridge or freezer
Torta Luna Rossa $55.00
A dessert with an almond biscuit base, Valrhona Ivoire (35%) white chocolate and tonka bean mousse, and a mixed berries cremoso. Perfect to enjoy from the fridge or freezer
Torta 5 Sensi $60.00
A dessert featuring Valrhona Ivoire (35%) white chocolate mousse, Valrhona Jivara (40%) milk chocolate mousse, Valrhona Madagascar (74%) dark chocolate mousse, and Gianduja praliné. Perfect to enjoy from the fridge or freezer.
Torta Tradizionale $60.00
A dessert with a chocolate biscuit base, pistachio mousse, chocolate gelato, and a crunchy pistachio topping. A frozen dessert, perfect to keep in your freezer and enjoy anytime!
Limited Edition - Torta Solstizio D'Estate $60.00
Limited Edition special dessert with an almond biscuit base soaked with Pineapple juice, Valrhona Ivoire (35%) white chocolate and coconut from Sulu' Island mousse, and Mango and Passion Fruit cremoso. Perfect to enjoy from the fridge or freezer

Gelato (Online) - Pastry/Dolci (Online)
Torta Nera $6.00
An indulgent slice of rich, velvety chocolate cake made from a secret family recipe, passed down for generations
Bocconotto Pistachio $4.75
Shortbread crust filled with rich, creamy pistachio for a perfectly nutty and flavorful bite
Bocconotto Crema & Amarena $4.75
Shortbread crust filled with velvety custard cream and tart sour cherries, topped with a light dusting of powdered sugar for a perfect balance of sweetness and flavor
Bocconotto Salted Caramel $4.75
Rich chocolate shortbread crust filled with silky salted caramel cream for the perfect sweet-salty balance
Bocconotto Pugliese $4.75
Shortbread crust filled with smooth coffee and almond cream for a rich, aromatic flavor
Gocciolato $4.50
Soft, fluffy brioche studded with Chocolate chips
Brioches $4.00
Soft, fluffy, house-made Brioches bun
Cornetto Empty $4.00
Flaky Italian croissant with a delicate, buttery texture, perfect on its own or paired with your favorite coffee
Chocolate Cornetto $4.00
Flaky Italian croissant filled with creamy chocolate
Pastry Cream Cornetto $4.00
Flaky Italian croissant filled with rich custard cream and topped with a light dusting of powdered sugar
Flan $4.75
Rich chocolate shortbread crust filled with smooth, creamy vanilla flan
Sporcamuss (Crispy Puff Pastry) $8.75
A traditional dessert from Bari (Italy), made with crispy puff pastry, filled with rich custard cream, and topped with a light dusting of powdered sugar. Warm it up briefly in the oven (Grill mode) for a softer, creamier filling and the best experience. A true taste of Apulian tradition!
Corona Pistachio & Raspberry $7.50
Sourdough brioche bun filled with rich Pistachio cream and Raspberry jelly, topped with a luscious Pistachio glaze
Corona Tiramisu' $7.50
Sourdough brioche bun filled with creamy tiramisu' filling and coffee sauce, finished with a dusting of cocoa powder
Corona Hazelnut $7.50
Sourdough brioche bun filled with smooth Hazelnut cream and topped with a rich dark chocolate Macadamia glaze
Cuoricini Gift Box (20 Pcs) $19.00
A delightful box of 20 heart-shaped shortbread cookies, chocolate and vanilla. Perfect for sharing or gifting
Praline Gift Box (3 Pcs) $8.00
A trio of rich chocolate truffles infused with rhum, perfect for gifting or indulging
Pugliesini Gift Box (10 Pcs) $19.00
Apulian almond cookies with a delicate citrusy flavor
Baresini Gift Box (10 Pcs) $19.00
Apulian almond cookies made with fig Vincotto and dried figs for a rich, authentic Italian flavor
Corona Tropicale - Pineapple & Coconut Cream $7.50
Sourdough brioche bun filled with pineapple and coconut cream, glazed with white chocolate and topped with coconut flakes and dried pineapple

Gelato (Online) - Crepes (Online)
Zucchero/Classic Crepes $8.00
Classic soft freshly made crepes topped with a light dusting of powdered sugar
Nutella Crepes $10.00
Soft, freshly made crepes filled with warm, creamy Nutella
Pistachio Crepes $10.00
Soft, freshly made crepes filled with warm, creamy pistachio spread
White Chocolate Crepes $10.00
Soft, freshly made crepes filled with warm, creamy white chocolate
Crema Gentile Crepes (Handmade Custard Cream) $10.00
Soft, freshly made crepes filled with our warm handmade Custard Cream

Gelato (Online) - Savory (Online)
Focaccia $5.50
Classic Italian focaccia topped with tomatoes, black olives, and extra virgin olive oil for a flavorful, rustic bite
Bocconotto Salato $4.75
Savory shortbread crust pastry filled with tomato jelly and creamy Parmigiano cheese bechamel. Heat in the microwave or oven for the best experience!

Gelato (Online) - Caffetteria (Online)
Hot Chocolate $5.50
Our homemade Italian-style hot chocolate, rich, velvety, and perfect for warming up your day
Latte $5.00
Creamy espresso beverage made with steamed milk, perfect for coffee enthusiasts.
Espresso $3.75
Rich, flavorful cup of espresso brewed to perfection.
Cappuccino $4.50
Classic espresso with steamed milk, topped with a layer of frothy foam.
Macchiato $4.00
A delicate balance of steamed milk and espresso, crowned with a light milk foam.
Americano $3.50
Espresso diluted with hot water, a classic, robust American-style coffee.
Cafe' Mocha $5.50
Espresso, chocolate, and steamed milk, topped with whipped cream.
Chai Latte $5.00
Aromatic spiced tea blended with steamed milk
Cold Brew Coffee $4.50
Smooth and refreshing cold brew
Double Espresso $4.50
Rich, bold double shot espresso, perfectly concentrated for a robust coffee experience.
Drip Coffee $3.00
Brewed coffee typically includes a rich, aromatic blend. Please note us to add milk or cream.
Hot Tea $3.75
Steaming, aromatic blend of finely selected tea leaves. Perfectly soothing.
Iced Americano $4.00
Chilled, refreshing espresso over ice—a classic Americano served cold.
Iced Espresso $4.25
Double shot of espresso poured over ice.
Iced Latte $5.00
Chilled espresso and milk, perfectly blended for a refreshing coffee experience.
Iced Tea $4.00
Chilled, Refreshing Brewed Tea, Perfectly Balanced for a Hot Day

Gelato (Online) - Sodas (Online)
Water Bolle Lurisia $3.00
Natural Italian sparkling water from Lurisia, known for its crisp and refreshing taste.
Water Stille Lurisia $3.00
Still mineral water from Lurisia, offering a pure and clear taste.
Lurisia Chinotto $3.50
Made from chinotto, a small bitter citrus fruit, this Italian soda offers a distinctive bittersweet flavor.
Lurisia Orange $3.50
Italian carbonated orange beverage with natural citrus essence.

Gelateria Gentile Details

Service options
Takeout
Delivery

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Table service

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Planning
Quick visit

Children
Good for kids

Gelateria Gentile Photos

Gelateria Gentile Location

Gelateria Gentile

New York New York County New York Amsterdam Avenue

498 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA

Gelateria Gentile Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 122 user reviews.

pistachiopastriescoffeeconehazelnutcrepedark chocolatecupflavorflan

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

We stumbled upon this charming café and decided to try the Tartufo Pistachio—it was absolutely delicious! The gelato was incredibly creamy, rich in flavor, and a delightful treat. The café has a lovely view of the street, making it a great spot to relax and watch the world go by. Inside, the atmosphere is warm and inviting, with tasteful decor and well-arranged tables, creating the perfect setting for a leisurely afternoon. If you're looking for a cozy spot with high-quality gelato, this place is definitely worth a visit!
April 27 · Maryam Bojarian
The musics inside were nice. The gelato was creamy and flavorful. They have kid’s cup and classic cup. It’s just a few dollars different. They also have other pastries available. Lovely atmosphere. Whoever picked the musics has good taste too. :)The napkins are not very absorbent in my opinion.
April 13 · G Frye
A Disappointing Experience at Geltaria – Not Worth the HypeI had high hopes for this visit to Geltaria and even raved about it to an elder in my family, eager to share what I remembered as amazing service and delicious gelato. Unfortunately, today’s experience was a complete letdown.Despite four employees being within eyesight, only one was actively serving customers. Shockingly, this same employee wiped his eyes and nose with his service gloves—a major hygiene red flag. The staff seemed confused about basic operations, and no one appeared ready or willing to step in to assist.After waiting more than 15 minutes, we were finally served, but the interaction was awkward and frustrating. The employee acted as though he couldn’t understand my order, and when I raised my voice slightly to clarify, he became visibly offended. I asked for an additional cup to serve my elder, but was given one the exact same size as mine. I reminded him that I had already paid for a cup and was just asking for a second one for convenience. Rather than asking clarifying questions, he once again acted offended, claiming not to understand the request.I then asked about the remaining pastries. Instead of providing an answer or checking, the employee stated I would “just need to walk around and see for myself,” even as another customer with a stroller stood nearby waiting. Rather than offering help, he walked away without so much as a thank you.To top things off, when I asked another employee for the name of the person who served me, I was told, “I’m new, I don’t know his name.” When I asked how he could be working with a stranger, he simply replied, “Yes.”All in all, this visit was marked by poor hygiene, long wait times, and astonishingly bad customer service. The gelato melted quickly, and the entire interaction left a sour taste in my mouth.There are at least three other gelato or ice cream spots within a four-block radius. If you’re looking for sticky gloves, confusion, and rudeness—by all means, line up here. Otherwise, save your time and go elsewhere
May 03 · Creative Solutions
A great gelateria reminiscent of gelato places in Italy. Gelato flavors held in silver pots, and flavors listed in Italian. A wide variety of flavors both milk/cream based and fruit flavors. Lots of seating, a warm environment, and a tasty assortment of pastries that I'll have to try next time. My small cup of stracciatela was 8$.
March 14 · Joseph Hewes
This is my favorite Gelato spot!I visited Gentile today and it was such a pleasant surprise, the staff was really nice and kind, very gentile, they allowed me to try some of the flavors and that made my decision even harder. I got a wafer cone with fragola è stracciatella, very classic combo but really tasty. The cones are beautiful and they give you a small cute cone on top.
July 01 · Sophie Hill