Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream: A West Creek, NJ Gem for Families

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Introduce

For many New Jersey locals, a true summer tradition involves finding that perfect local spot for a delicious ice cream cone. In West Creek, that spot is undoubtedly Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream. This charming ice cream stand has become a beloved destination for families, not just for its fantastic frozen treats, but also for its welcoming and engaging atmosphere. Located conveniently on Main Street, which is also Route 9, Jeffreeze is a place where every scoop feels like a classic summer memory waiting to happen.

The core of what makes Jeffreeze so popular is, of course, the ice cream itself. Customers consistently praise the quality and flavor, with one review highlighting the "delicious ice cream!" and specifically mentioning the "Brownie Downie Sunday and Black Cherry ice cream." The description of these treats as "delicious and very generous scoops" is a powerful testament to the value and quality the shop provides. The variety of options is also a major plus, with a wide selection of flavors and "fun Sunday choices" that ensure there's always something new and exciting to try, no matter how many times you visit.

Beyond the menu, the overall experience at Jeffreeze is what truly makes it a local gem. The shop is described as a "small, with an 'order here' window, and a 'pick up here' window," creating a classic, old-fashioned ice cream stand feel. The service is also a highlight, as one customer noted that the young man who prepared their order was "welcoming and quick. He did a beautiful job!" This kind of friendly and efficient service is a cornerstone of a great local business and contributes to the positive, community-oriented atmosphere.

What truly sets Jeffreeze apart, especially for families, is the added amenities. The shop has "several tables and places to sit and enjoy your Ice-cream," but it also goes a step further by including "a few slides and climbing apparatus for young children." This thoughtful addition makes it the perfect destination for families, as kids can burn off some energy while parents relax and enjoy their treats. This unique feature transforms a simple ice cream run into a fun outing, making it a favorite for parents in the area.

It is important to note for new customers that Jeffreeze is a "CASH ONLY" business. However, the owners have thought ahead and provided a convenient solution by having an "ATM machine" on site. This small detail shows a commitment to customer convenience and ensures that everyone can enjoy their treats without any hassle. This kind of practicality, combined with the excellent product and fun atmosphere, speaks volumes about the business's dedication to its patrons.

The positive reviews consistently praise the value and generosity of the portions. One customer’s comment that "small sizes are big!" perfectly summarizes the fantastic value Jeffreeze offers. In a world where smaller portions are often the norm, finding a place that provides generous scoops feels like a wonderful surprise. The shop's location on Route 9, described as "in and out of the way," also adds to its charm, making it a special discovery for those who find it and a cherished tradition for those who already know about it.

In conclusion, Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream has all the ingredients of a beloved local institution: delicious, generously-portioned ice cream, friendly and efficient service, and a family-friendly environment with a playground. It's a place where you can create lasting summer memories, and its unique features make it a standout destination in the West Creek area. The combination of classic charm and modern convenience ensures that it will remain a cherished spot for New Jersey locals for years to come.

Location and Accessibility

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream is located at 381 Main St #9314 in West Creek, New Jersey. The shop is situated on Route 9, a major thoroughfare in the area, making it easy to find and access. Its location provides a convenient stop for locals and those traveling through the southern parts of New Jersey.

The shop offers "lots of parking," which is a huge benefit for families and groups, ensuring a stress-free visit. Its presence on a main road means it's accessible by car, and the open space around it makes it easy for families to gather and relax. The simple, stand-style setup with separate order and pick-up windows also makes for a smooth and quick service experience.

Services Offered

A wide variety of delicious old-fashioned ice cream flavors.
"Generous scoops" and large portions, even in smaller sizes.
Fun and creative Sunday choices, like the "Brownie Downie."
Friendly and quick service from a welcoming staff.
A cash-only business with a convenient on-site ATM.

Features / Highlights

Highly praised for its generous scoops and great value.
Unique family-friendly environment with slides and climbing apparatus for children.
A classic, old-fashioned ice cream stand design with separate ordering and pickup windows.
An on-site ATM for customer convenience due to its cash-only policy.
Lots of parking and places to sit and enjoy your ice cream.

Contact Information

Address: 381 Main St #9314, West Creek, NJ 08092, USA

Phone: (609) 294-2600

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream is an ideal spot for New Jersey locals, especially those in the West Creek and surrounding areas, for several compelling reasons.

First, it embodies the spirit of a classic, family-friendly summer outing. The combination of delicious, generously portioned ice cream and a small playground for kids makes it a perfect destination for families looking for a fun and affordable activity. It's a place where parents can relax while their children play, creating a truly enjoyable experience for everyone.

Second, its commitment to quality and value is something that the local community truly appreciates. The large scoops and delicious flavors ensure that customers feel like they are getting a great deal, which builds trust and loyalty. This focus on providing a superior product is what transforms a simple ice cream stand into a beloved community institution.

Finally, its old-fashioned charm and the personal, friendly service make it a place that feels authentically local. It’s a business with character that has integrated itself into the community’s summer traditions. For New Jersey residents, Jeffreeze is more than just a place to get dessert; it's a part of what makes their local area feel special.

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Vibe

TIPS FOR THE GANG
Tips For The Gang
Please feel free to add "a little something "extra for our staff. They are incredible, hardworking, polite, fun, loving and all-around great humans.

Cups
Soft Serve Cups
Classic Jeffreeze soft serve ice cream. They're bigger than you think!
Hard Ice Cream Cups
They're bigger than you think! Baby is 2 scoops, Small is 3 scoops, Medium is 4 scoops, Large is 5 scoops! Mix flavors if you want, go ahead get crazy!
Add A Waffle Bowl $2.30
Dog Cup $3.45
Don't forget your best friend! Treat your pup to our vanilla soft serve topped with a dog bone!
8oz Pre Packaged Water Ice $3.50
Pre packaged Philadelphia Water Ice ( your choice of Cherry, Chocolate, Cotton Candy, Lemonade, Mango, Rainbow, Tropical Rainbow, Watermelon, subject to availability)

Sundaes
Soft Serve Sundae
Our legendary Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist soft serve with a topping of your choice, whipped cream and cherry. (For quality purposes, hot toppings and waffle bowl, if selected, will be served on the side. Additional toppings available for extra charge).
Hard Sundae
Our hand dipped "hard" ice cream sundae, including one topping and whipped cream and a cherry. Choose from over 30 flavors or if you can't decide, get crazy with it and mix it up! (For quality purposes, hot toppings and waffle bowl, if selected, will be served on the side. Additional toppings available for extra charge).
Brownie A La Mode $10.75
Sometimes, a large just doesn't do it! Our brownie Ala Mode comes in a large banana boat, includes 3 mouthwatering brownie bites, 3 mountains of ice cream (go ahead choose up to 3 flavors), and gobs of hot fudge, caramel or hot peanut. (For quality purposes, hot toppings will be served on the side. Waffle Bowl not applicable for Brownie a la Mode).
Banana Split $10.75
This, without a doubt is one of Americas favorite ice cream treats. Our classic banana split is "over the top" yummy. We start with a banana base, 3 mounds of ice cream (soft or hard), 3 toppings of your choice finished with whipped cream and a cherry. Remember, its healthy - there's fruit! (For quality purposes, hot toppings will be served on the side. Waffle bowl not applicable for Banana Split).

Specialty Sundaes
Salty Dog
The original Jeffreeze Specialty Sundae and our BEST SELLER! Vanilla Soft serve, caramel, peanuts, sea salt, hard chocolate dip, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Nutty Buddy
Vanilla soft serve topped with hot fudge, hot peanut butter, butter fingers, Reese pieces, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Dark Side
Chocolate soft serve topped with hot fudge, cake crunch, sea salt, chocolate dip, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Samoa
Chocolate soft serve topped with caramel, hot fudge, toasted coconut, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Cookie Castle
Vanilla Soft serve topped with hot fudge, chocolate chips, cookie dough bites, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Dusty Road
Twist soft serve topped with malt powder, hot fudge, oreos, whipped cream and cherry!
Chunky Jeff
Chocolate soft serve topped with sliced banana, hot peanut butter, peanuts, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
PB+J
Throwing it back to your elementary school days! Banana ice cream, cold peanut butter, strawberry topping, whipped cream and a cherry.
Bake Shop
Twist soft serve, hot fudge, warm brownie, WARM chocolate chip cookies, m+m's, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Drownie Brownie
Half Peanut butter brownie ice cream, half chocolate soft serve topped with brownie dough bites, chocolate chip cookies, hot fudge, hot peanut butter, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Jersey Turtle
Chocolate soft serve topped with caramel, chocolate syrup, sea salt, pecans, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Razzle Dazzle
Twist soft serve topped with chocolate syrup, raspberry syrup, chocolate chips, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Kit-Katasrope
Twist Ice cream topped with warm marshmallow, hot fudge, kit -kats, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
'Pie' Sundae
Vanilla soft serve topped with caramel, graham crackers, your choice of fruit topping (pineapple, strawberry, cherry or apple), whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Smores
Vanilla soft serve, topped with hot fudge, warm marshmallow, graham cracker, chocolate chips, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Cup Of Dirt
Chocolate soft serve topped with hot fudge, oreos, gummy worms, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)
Almond Joy
Hard Coconut Ice cream topped with hot fudge, almonds, whipped cream and a cherry. (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Blizzards
Blizzard
Our Blizzard is a blend of our delicious soft serve ice cream (Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist) mixed perfectly with generous scoops of a topping of your choice.
Apple Pie Blizzard
Vanilla Soft serve with crushed graham crackers, hot caramel, and apple pie topping mixed in!
Kit Kat Blizzard
Vanilla soft serve blended with strawberry syrup, white coconut flakes, and kit-kats!
Paddy Blizzard
Girl Scout Cookie Lovers, REJOICE! Vanilla soft serve mixed with mint syrup, chocolate chips, with crushed Thin a Mint cookies!
Banana-Nana Blizzard
Jeffreeze's take on Chunky Monkey! Vanilla soft serve mixed with cold peanut butter, chocolate chips, and chopped up bananas.

Shakes
Soft Ice Cream Milk Shake
If we're honest, our milkshakes are the ROCKSTARS of our menu. Try one out for yourself...you'll see what we mean! Soft Ice Cream shake flavors are Vanilla, Chocolate, Twist, and Black and White.
Hard Ice Cream Milk Shake
If we're honest, our milkshakes are the ROCKSTARS of our menu. Try one out for yourself...you'll see what we mean! Pick any of our hard ice cream flavors!
Malt
Add some malt powder to your shake for some nutty, extra-milky flavor that is absolutely addictive!!!
Mango Tango Shake $7.90
Allow us to transport you to a tropical island with the Mango Tango! Mango water ice mixed with vanilla soft serve, bananas, strawberry topping, and pineapple topping, finished with whipped cream and a cherry! (20 oz)
Creamsicle Shake $7.90
Vanilla Soft serve mixed with orange soda.(20 oz)
Paddy Shake $7.70
Get your Irish on with our Paddy Shake. It is a delicious (20 oz) minty flavor shake that will be your "pot of gold" drizzled with fudge and topped with a thin mint cookie. Made with vanilla soft serve
Pina Colada $8.90
If you like getting caught in the rain, chances are, you're going to love Jeffreeze's Pina Colada Shake! Coconut ice cream & crushed pineapple. (20 oz)

Floats
Jefflati $8.10
Soft serve ice cream and Italian ice - the best of both worlds! Your choice of soft serve ice cream layered with your choice of water ice. Choose from Cherry, Rainbow, Cotton Candy-Bubblegum, Mango, Tropical Rainbow, and Watermelon Ice.
Shirley Temple Float $7.95
Jeffreeze's take on a classic! Soft Serve vanilla ice cream with sprite and cherry juice. (Float may be delivered with soda packaged separately for quality purposes)
Root Beer Float $7.05
This is the classic root beer float, a crowd pleaser.

Drinks
Soda $1.45
Water $1.45

Quarts
Soft Serve Quart $10.00
The best way to ensure you never run out of your favorite Jeffreeze flavors :) Your choice of vanilla, chocolate, or twist soft serve!
Hard Ice Cream Quart $10.50
The best way to ensure you never run out of your favorite Jeffreeze flavors :) Your choice of hard ice cream.

Pies
Soft Ice Cream Pie $33.25
Grab a Jeffreeze Pie for your next celebration! Pie flavor availability subject to inventory levels. Flavors include Cookie Castle, Nutty Buddy, Fudge Crunch, Samoa, Dark Side of Spoon, and Cup of Dirt. Pies need very little thawing so dive right in. Serves 12 easily or 1, no judging here!!!

Sundae Boxes
Standard - 4 Servings Box $28.00
This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 4 small soft serve cups or B. 1 quart of ice cream (soft or hard) and any 3 toppings listed here: Rainbow Sprinkles, Chocolate Sprinkles, syrups, cake crunch, or gummies. Box includes 4 regular or sugar cones. Cherrys included in box.
Standard - 6 Servings Box $39.00
This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 6 small soft serve cups or B. 2 quart of ice cream and any 4 toppings listed here; Rainbow Sprinkles, Chocolate Sprinkles, syrups, cake crunch, or gummies. Box includes 6 regular or sugar cones. Cherrys included in box.
Premium - 4 Servings Box $33.00
This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 4 small cups (soft or hard) or B. 1 quart of ice cream (soft or hard) and any 4 toppings. Box includes 4 regular or sugar cones. Cherries included in box.
Premium - 6 Servings Box $43.00
This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 6 small cups or B. 2 quarts of ice cream (soft or hard) and any 5 toppings. Box includes 6 regular or sugar cones. Cherries included in box.
Gold - 4 Servings Box $38.00
This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 4 small cups (soft or hard) or B) 2 quarts of ice cream (soft or hard) and any 4 toppings. Box includes 4 cake, waffle, sugar, or specialty cones. Cherries included in box.
Gold - 6 Servings Box $44.00
This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 6 small cups (soft or hard) or B. 3 quarts of ice cream (soft or hard) and any 5 toppings. Box includes 6 cake, waffle, sugar, or specialty cones. Cherries included in box.

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Details

Service options
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Dining options
Table service

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Trending

Crowd
Groups

Payments
Cash-only

Children
Good for kids

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Photos

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Picture 1

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Picture 2

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Picture 3

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Picture 4

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Picture 5

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Picture 6

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Picture 7

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Picture 8

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Picture 9

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Location

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream

New Jersey Ocean County Eagleswood West Creek Main Street

381 Main St #9314, West Creek, NJ 08092, USA

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Reviews

An average rating of ★4.8 from 591 user reviews.

pricessundaeflavorsconecashshakeplay areavanillacheckersbrownie

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Delicious ice cream! We really enjoyed the “Brownie Downie” Sunday and Black Cherry ice cream. Both were delicious and very generous scoops. CASH ONLY.There is a lot to choose from, lots of flavors and fun Sunday choices.The ice cream stand is small, with an “order here” window, and a “pick up here” window on the other side. There is a step up to the window. The young man who prepared our order was welcoming and quick. He did a beautiful job!Lots of children. There are several tables and places to sit and enjoy your Ice-cream, as well as a few slides and climbing apparatus for young children. There’s an ATM machine since this is a cash only business. Lots of parking.
May 21 · Tatiana Hoover
Very good ice cream in and out of the way area well it's on Route 9 in West Creek. Trendy service reasonable prices and even a small sizes are big!
July 22 · H Black
Great place off the island for treats and fun. Old school family friendly atmosphere, fun recipes and good old fashioned ice cream. Be warned the brownie a la mode is huge and comes with six scoops of ice cream plus toppings. The kids play area is also a nice touch, and the service was very friendly and fast. Cash only but they have an atm on premise.
October 11 · Sean Hyde
My boyfriend and I absolutely LOVE this place! The ice cream is great and the topping are delicious!!! My favorite is the Nutty Buddy, I get it all the time!!! Thank you Jeffreeze for making such awesome ice cream! A++++
April 01 · Nicole Cochran
The best around.Cash only.Fast service and kind workers.Plenty of parking and HUGE portions. Dessert for dinner vibes for sure!YOU GOTTA TRY!
May 28 · Nathan Mattero