Mike's Custard Shack- Soft Serve & Italian Ice Introduce
For residents of New Jersey, particularly those in the charming coastal town of Ocean City, finding a reliable spot for a quick and refreshing treat is always a welcome convenience. Mike's Custard Shack – Soft Serve & Italian Ice, located at 210 E 55th St, offers a local option for those craving classic frozen desserts. Specializing in both creamy soft serve and vibrant Italian ice, this spot aims to provide a straightforward and accessible sweet escape for families and individuals enjoying the laid-back atmosphere of Ocean City's quieter neighborhoods.
As a local establishment, Mike's Custard Shack focuses on delivering the essential frozen treats that many New Jerseyans love, perfect for a warm summer day or a simple evening indulgence. While experiences can vary, the core offering caters to popular preferences for both soft serve and Italian ice. This article will provide an overview of Mike's Custard Shack, detailing its convenient location, the range of services it offers, its key features, and why it remains a relevant option for locals in the Ocean City area.
Mike's Custard Shack – Soft Serve & Italian Ice is conveniently located at 210 E 55th St, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA. This address places it in a more residential and community-focused part of Ocean City, away from the immediate hustle and bustle of the main Boardwalk. For locals, this means easier access and potentially less congestion, making it a practical choice for a neighborhood treat. Its location on E 55th Street provides straightforward access for those driving or biking within the Ocean City area.
Being situated in a residential section, parking is often more readily available compared to the highly trafficked boardwalk areas, contributing to a more relaxed visit. For residents living in the south end of Ocean City or those staying in rental properties nearby, Mike's Custard Shack is often within easy walking or biking distance. This localized accessibility makes it a convenient stop for families returning from the beach, or simply for a spontaneous dessert run without needing to venture far. Its position in a quieter part of town enhances its appeal as a true neighborhood ice cream spot for the New Jersey community.
Services Offered:
- Soft Serve Custard: A primary offering, known for its creamy texture.
- Italian Ice: A dairy-free, refreshing frozen dessert, with various flavors.
- Miklati: A combination of Italian Ice and Custard Swirl, offering a unique mixed treat.
- Shakes: Likely available given the soft serve and Italian ice options. (Based on typical ice cream shop offerings, though not explicitly detailed in provided reviews for this location.)
- Cups and Cones: Standard serving options for both soft serve and Italian ice.
- Toppings: Sprinkles are available, though a charge applies.
- Pre-packed Pints and Quarts: Some ice cream shops offer these for take-home convenience, and while not explicitly stated in reviews, menu information from related businesses suggests this might be an option.
Features / Highlights:
- Dual offerings: Specializes in both soft serve custard and Italian ice, providing options for different preferences.
- Pineapple Twist (from a generic search for "Mike's Custard Shack menu" but not explicitly tied to this address): This may be a popular flavor, given its mention in a general menu search.
- Accessibility: Located in a residential area, potentially offering easier access and parking compared to boardwalk locations.
Contact Information:
Address: 210 E 55th St, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA
Phone: (609) 399-3464
Mobile Phone: +1 609-399-3464
For locals in New Jersey, particularly those residing in or frequently visiting Ocean City, Mike's Custard Shack – Soft Serve & Italian Ice offers a suitable and convenient option for frozen treats. While there are some mixed reviews regarding service and pricing of certain add-ons, its core offerings and neighborhood accessibility make it a relevant spot for the community.
Firstly, the location at 210 E 55th St provides distinct advantages for residents. Unlike the bustling boardwalk, this spot is nestled in a quieter, more residential part of Ocean City. This means easier access for locals who live nearby, a less crowded environment, and potentially simpler parking. For families, children, or anyone looking for a quick, low-key ice cream run without the full tourist experience, Mike's Custard Shack offers a convenient neighborhood solution. It's the kind of place you can quickly bike or walk to from a nearby rental property or home.
Secondly, the dual focus on both soft serve custard and Italian ice caters to a broad spectrum of local preferences. Many New Jerseyans have a fondness for classic soft serve, and Italian ice offers a refreshing, often dairy-free alternative, especially on hot summer days. While the reviews provided do not specifically praise the taste of the ice cream itself with glowing terms, one review did state "Ice cream was okay," implying it is a decent option, and the "pineapple twist" in a broader context is a popular flavor for this type of establishment. For those seeking these specific types of frozen treats, Mike's provides a dedicated local source.
It is important for local users to be aware of the feedback regarding service and pricing of items like sprinkles. Transparency around pricing, especially for small add-ons, is something many locals value. However, the presence of an independent, neighborhood-focused ice cream shop often holds intrinsic value for a community, offering a familiar spot close to home. Despite these points, its primary role as a convenient local vendor for popular frozen desserts makes it a relevant choice.
In conclusion, Mike's Custard Shack – Soft Serve & Italian Ice is suitable for New Jersey locals in Ocean City due to its accessible, neighborhood location and its offerings of beloved soft serve and Italian ice. While individual experiences may vary, it serves as a practical and nearby option for those seeking a convenient frozen treat without the need to venture to more congested areas.
Mike's Custard Shack- Soft Serve & Italian Ice Details
Service options
- Takeout
- Delivery
Atmosphere
- Casual
Children
- Good for kids
Mike's Custard Shack- Soft Serve & Italian Ice Photos

Mike's Custard Shack- Soft Serve & Italian Ice Location
Mike's Custard Shack- Soft Serve & Italian Ice
210 E 55th St, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA
Mike's Custard Shack- Soft Serve & Italian Ice Reviews
Ice cream was okay. They do charge a $1 for sprinkles which is crazy, especially because it was like a teaspoon. The kid at the window had ear buds in the whole time and didn't seem to comprehend what was going on.
July 09 · Daniel UBad service. Women who got us our ice cream order gave us our money back but our change in the tip drawer. Good ice cream but wasn’t nicely swirled.
June 24 · Emily Brubaker- August 25 · Josh Jamison
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

301 E 55th St, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA

4001 West Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA

3339 West Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA

3255 Asbury Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA

3255 Asbury Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA

137 US-9, Marmora, NJ 08223, USA

109 NJ-50, Ocean View, NJ 08230, USA

2100 Asbury Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA

1363 Asbury Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA

1320 Boardwalk, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA

1242 Boardwalk, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA

1206 Ocean Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





