New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream

For residents of Ohio, finding a truly great ice cream shop is more than just a search for a dessert—it’s a quest for a local tradition. New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream, nestled in Hartville, is a beloved institution that perfectly embodies this spirit. As its name suggests, the business prides itself on crafting its own ice cream, a practice that results in a noticeably richer and more flavorful product. This commitment to quality and a classic, no-frills approach has made it a cherished destination for families, friends, and anyone with a sweet tooth. The shop is a testament to the idea that simple, high-quality ingredients and friendly service can create an unforgettable experience, turning a routine stop into a cherished memory.

The appeal of New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream lies in its authenticity. It’s an old-school ice cream stand where the process of ordering and receiving your treat is part of the charm. Customers order at one window and pick up their cones or sundaes at another, a simple system that adds to the shop's nostalgic feel. The prices are consistently mentioned by patrons as being a key highlight, with a great value for the generous portions served. This affordability, combined with the superior quality of the homemade ice cream, makes it a highly attractive option for families and individuals alike. It’s a place where you can get a fantastic treat without breaking the bank, a feature that is highly valued in any local community.

Customer reviews paint a picture of a business that is not only dedicated to its products but also to its patrons. One customer raves about the amazing ice cream and great prices, noting that they got two cones for a very reasonable amount. They also praise the staff for being "very friendly," which highlights the warm and welcoming atmosphere. This positive feedback on both the product and the service is a powerful indicator of the shop's commitment to creating a positive experience for every person who visits. The short wait times, even during busy periods, are another testament to the staff’s efficiency and hard work.

Another review emphasizes the quality of the sundaes, with one customer declaring a peanut butter sundae to be "the best sundae I've had, outside of a Friendly's!!" This comparison to a well-known establishment speaks volumes about the quality of the desserts at New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream. The detailed description of the sundae, complete with hot fudge, Reese's cup bits, and whipped cream, proves that the shop doesn't skimp on the toppings, offering a truly decadent experience. This particular customer's loyalty is secured by the fact that the shop is "close to my campground and I'll definitely be back for plenty more," indicating that its reputation extends beyond the immediate local residents to visitors in the area.

While a visit might require a bit of a drive for some, as one reviewer points out, the consensus is that the trip is "worth it." This speaks to the reputation and quality of the ice cream, which is a powerful draw. The deliciousness of the homemade flavors, the affordability, and the friendly service combine to create a compelling reason for people to make the journey. This article will provide a detailed overview of what makes New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream such a special part of the local landscape, highlighting its offerings, location, and the features that have earned it a loyal following.

Location and Accessibility

New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is located at 14738 Ravenna Ave NE, Hartville, OH 44632, USA. While it may be a bit of a drive for some, its location is a known destination for those seeking quality ice cream in the region. The shop's presence in Hartville places it in a charming, community-focused area, which adds to its local appeal. As a drive-up stand, it's a convenient stop for a quick treat on a warm day. The process of ordering at one window and picking up at another is efficient and simple, making the experience smooth even during busy periods.

The accessibility of this location, while perhaps a destination trip for some, is a part of its charm. It's not a fast-food chain on every corner; it's a place you intentionally go to for a special, high-quality treat. This makes the experience feel more like a mini-outing, perfect for a family adventure or a scenic drive. For locals in the Hartville area, it's a reliable and cherished spot that's an easy stop at any time.

Services Offered

New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream offers a classic menu of frozen treats and desserts, all built around their signature homemade ice cream.

• P: Homemade Ice Cream: A variety of flavors are available, including classics like vanilla and butter pecan, all made in-house.
• P: Cones: Served in various sizes, from small to large, offering great value for the price.
• P: Sundaes: A comprehensive sundae menu, including specialty options with hot fudge, nuts, whipped cream, and cherries.
• P: Milkshakes and Blasts: A selection of thick and creamy blended drinks.
• P: Pints and Quarts: Ice cream can be purchased in larger quantities to take home and enjoy.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream apart are its distinctive features that enhance the customer experience.

• P: Amazing Homemade Ice Cream: The star feature, with a rich, creamy texture and delicious flavors that receive consistent praise.
• P: Great Prices: Customers frequently mention the excellent value, getting generous portions for an affordable cost.
• P: Friendly Staff: The people working at the shop are known for being very welcoming and pleasant, which makes every visit more enjoyable.
• P: Efficient Service: A two-window ordering and pickup system ensures that wait times are short, even when the shop is busy.
• P: Decadent Sundaes: The sundaes are highly praised for their quality and generous toppings, standing out as a must-try item.
• P: Cash-Only: It is a cash-only establishment, which adds to its nostalgic, old-school charm.

Contact Information

For more information about New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream, you can visit their location:

Address: 14738 Ravenna Ave NE, Hartville, OH 44632, USA

There is no publicly available phone number for New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream at this time.

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

For residents of Ohio, New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is a perfect local destination. It’s a business that represents the best of what a small, community-focused shop can be. The dedication to making homemade ice cream ensures a superior product, while the friendly staff and great prices make it an accessible and enjoyable treat for everyone. It’s a place that fosters a sense of local pride, offering a unique product that can't be found at a national chain. For those living nearby or those willing to make the short drive, it's a reliable source of high-quality dessert and a great place to make memories with family and friends.

The experience of visiting the shop is a true local tradition, whether it's for a simple cone or a decadent sundae. The fact that customers are willing to drive a distance to get there speaks volumes about the quality and value they find. New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream is a testament to the idea that a great product, fair prices, and a friendly atmosphere are the ingredients for a successful and beloved local business. It's a true gem in the Hartville community and a must-visit for any ice cream lover in the region.

New Baltimore Homemade Ice Cream

14738 Ravenna Ave NE, Hartville, OH 44632, USA