Ice Cream Shop
Ice Cream ShopSweet ScoopsIce Cream Shops Near Me
ConnecticutDelawareDistrict of ColumbiaIllinoisIndianaIowaKentuckyMarylandMassachusettsMichiganMissouriNew HampshireNew JerseyNew YorkOhioPennsylvaniaTennesseeVermontVirginiaWest VirginiaWisconsin
Ice Cream ShopIce Cream Shops Near MeNew JerseyCape May CountyCape MayIce Cream Shops in Carpenters LanePeace Pie
Peace Pie ico

Peace Pie

Ice cream shop ★4.0·$$

326 Carpenters Ln, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

4.0
Unique ice cream sandwich that we really wanted to try when we visited Cape May. The place looks really colourful and pretty on the outside and the peanut butter brownie sandwich we tried tasted great! - Neha Vl
Peace Pie Overview Intro Vibe Detail Photos Location Reviews

Peace Pie Introduce

For residents and visitors of Cape May, New Jersey, seeking a unique twist on classic frozen desserts, Peace Pie offers an intriguing and often sought-after experience. This ice cream shop stands out by specializing in gourmet ice cream sandwiches, moving beyond the traditional scoop to deliver a distinctive treat. It has carved a niche for itself as a destination for those looking for something a bit different, a delightful combination of creamy ice cream nestled between two soft, flavorful cookies or brownies. Peace Pie aims to provide a memorable dessert experience, adding a touch of innovative sweetness to the vibrant culinary scene of Cape May.

Peace Pie strives to be more than just a place to grab a cold treat; it's about offering a unique product that sparks curiosity and satisfies a specific craving. Their focus on the ice cream sandwich format allows for creative flavor combinations and a handheld dessert that's perfect for enjoying while exploring the charming streets of Cape May. While individual experiences may vary, the allure of a unique ice cream sandwich has drawn many to its doors, making it a point of interest for both first-time visitors and long-time residents of this picturesque New Jersey town. It's a place that caters to those with a sweet tooth looking for an unconventional dessert.

Peace Pie is conveniently located at 326 Carpenters Ln, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA. This address places it within the heart of Cape May's bustling and historic downtown area. Carpenters Lane is known for its charming shops, boutiques, and eateries, making Peace Pie easily accessible to those exploring the town center. Its location in a high-foot-traffic area means it's a popular stop for locals and tourists meandering through Cape May's quaint streets, providing a perfect opportunity to grab a unique dessert during a leisurely afternoon or evening stroll.

The accessibility of Peace Pie is generally quite good due to its central location. Carpenters Lane is a pedestrian-friendly area, encouraging visitors to explore on foot. For those driving, various parking options, including street parking and municipal lots, are typically available within reasonable walking distance, though finding a spot can sometimes be challenging during peak season. Being situated amidst other local businesses makes it easy to incorporate a visit to Peace Pie into a broader outing, whether you're shopping, dining, or simply enjoying the atmosphere of downtown Cape May. Its vibrant and pretty exterior also makes it easily recognizable to those passing by, inviting them in for a unique frozen treat.

Services Offered:

  • Specializing in unique, pre-made gourmet ice cream sandwiches, offering a distinctive dessert experience different from traditional scooped ice cream.
  • Providing a variety of flavor combinations for their ice cream sandwiches, such as peanut butter brownie, allowing for diverse taste preferences.
  • Focusing on a grab-and-go model for convenience, catering to customers who wish to enjoy their treat while exploring Cape May.

Features / Highlights:

  • Offers a "unique ice cream sandwich" concept, distinguishing it from other dessert establishments in the area.
  • Known for its "colorful and pretty" exterior, creating an inviting and visually appealing storefront that draws attention.
  • Has specific popular flavors like the "peanut butter brownie sandwich," which has been noted for its great taste.
  • Serves pre-made ice cream sandwiches, which can be convenient for quick service, though some customers have noted they may require time to thaw to optimal consistency.
  • Located on Carpenters Lane, a vibrant and popular pedestrian street in downtown Cape May, ensuring high visibility and easy access for those exploring the area.

Contact Information:

Address: 326 Carpenters Ln, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

Phone: (609) 435-5321

Mobile Phone: +1 609-435-5321

Conclusion: Why Peace Pie is Suitable for Locals

For residents of New Jersey, particularly those in the Cape May area, Peace Pie offers a distinct and often appealing option for a sweet treat. Its primary suitability for locals lies in its unique product offering: the gourmet ice cream sandwich. In a market often saturated with traditional ice cream parlors, Peace Pie carves out its own niche, providing a different kind of frozen dessert experience. For those looking to try something beyond the typical cone or cup, or simply seeking variety, Peace Pie presents an intriguing alternative that can become a regular indulgence.

The shop's location on Carpenters Lane is another significant advantage for locals. This area is a central hub for shopping, dining, and leisure in Cape May. Being able to easily pop into Peace Pie while running errands, meeting friends, or enjoying a downtown stroll adds to its convenience and makes it a natural part of the local routine. Its vibrant exterior also contributes to the lively atmosphere of the lane, making it a noticeable and attractive stop for residents.

While individual customer experiences may vary, particularly regarding product temperature or amenities like seating and trash disposal, the core appeal of Peace Pie for locals remains its specialized product. For someone living in Cape May who has frequented other dessert spots, the unique ice cream sandwich provides a novel reason to visit. It caters to a desire for distinctive culinary experiences within the local community, offering a specific type of treat that may not be readily available elsewhere. Its existence enriches the local dessert landscape, providing residents with more diverse choices for satisfying their sweet cravings. Despite potential areas for improvement in customer experience, the novelty and taste of its signature product ensure its place as a noteworthy local business.

Peace Pie Vibe

  • ONLINE & INSTORE

  • Key Lime Pie $8.59

    Our Delicious Key Lime Pie Mousse with a Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream Served Between Our Crunchy Cinnamon Shortbread Cookies

  • Boston Cream Pie $8.59

    Shortbread Cookie, Custard, Chocolate Mousse, Vanilla Ice Cream

  • Coconut Cream $8.59

    Shortbread Cookie, Coconut Custard, Vanilla Ice Cream

  • Thin Mint $8.59

    Our house-made whipped mint mousse, over chocolate ice cream on two chocolate shortbread cookies

  • Caramel Apple $8.59

    Cinnamon Cookie, Apple Pie Filling, Caramel, Vanilla Ice Cream

  • Cinnamon Bun $8.59

    Cinnamon Swirl Ice Cream topped with a layer of our house-made Caramel and Vanilla Mousse sandwiched between two Cinnamon Shortbread Cookies

  • PB Blondie $8.59

    Butter shortbread cookie with peanut butter mousse and brownies on vanilla ice cream.

  • Coffee Toffee $8.59

    Our Classic Coffee Ice Cream Sandwich, topped with our House-made Caramel and Toffee Crumble on Chocolate Shortbread Cookies

  • S'mores - Regular Price $8.59

    Peace Pie's frozen take on the American Classic Chocolate Ice Cream with a layer of Chocolate Mousse and Mini Marshmallows sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies!

  • Chocolate Raspberry $8.59

    Chocolate shortbread cookie with chocolate mousse on raspberry ice cream

  • Creme Brulee $8.59

    Vanilla ice cream topped with a layer of vanilla custard and house made caramel with toffee crumble between two butter shortbread cookies

  • PB Brownie $8.59

    Chocolate shortbread cookie with peanut butter chiffon, caramel, and brownies on peanut butter ice cream.

  • Molten Chocolate $8.59

    Our Signature all chocolate pie, Chocolate Ice Cream with a layer of Chocolate Mousse sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies

  • Peanut Butter Cup $8.59

    Peace Pie's Peanut Butter Cup is the perfect combination of Chocolate Ice Cream and our Deliciously Creamy Peanut Butter Mousse on two crispy Butter Shortbread Cookies

  • Jersey Devil $8.59

    The one and only JERSEY DEVIL Peace Pie is all Red White & Blue with Blueberry Ice Cream topped with a layer of Cherry Pie Filling and Vanilla Mousse sandwiched between two Butter Shortbread Cookies

  • Caramel Brownie $8.59

    Our Best Seller from the very start The Salted Caramel Brownie is Vanilla Ice Cream topped with our House-made caramel and fudge brownie bites sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies!

  • Candy Bar $8.59

    Our House-made Custard with Banana Butter over a scoop of vanilla ice cream sandwiched with two graham cracker cookies

  • Triple Vanilla $8.59

    Creamy Vanilla Mousse over a scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream on our Original Butter Shortbread Cookies

  • Rocky Road $8.59

    Rocky Road reinvented with our Delicious Chocolate Mousse, swirled with Almond Slivers and Mini Marshmallows over Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwiched Between Two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies

  • Banana Cream $8.59

    Our House-made Custard with Banana Butter over a scoop of vanilla ice cream sandwiched with two graham cracker cookies

  • Creamsicle $8.59

    Refreshing Orange Sherbet topped with our creamy Vanilla Mousse on Butter Shortbread Cookies

  • Peaches N' Cream $8.59

    Peach Ice Cream topped with our signature Vanilla Mousse, sandwiched between two Graham Cracker Shortbread Cookies

  • PB Cookie Dough $8.59

    Chocolate shortbread cookie with peanut butter chiffon and cookie dough on chocolate ice cream.

  • Party Pie $8.59

    Chocolate Ice Cream topped with a layer of Vanilla Mousse and Rainbow Sprinkles sandwiched between two Butter Shortbread Cookies

  • The Elvis $8.59

    Our delicious house-made banana butter with creamy peanut butter mousse over chocolate ice cream sandwiched between two crunchy chocolate shortbread cookies

  • Strawberry Shortcake $8.59

    A refreshing scoop of Strawberry Ice Cream topped with a layer of creamy Vanilla Mousse, sandwiched between two Butter Shortbread Cookies

  • Blueberry Lemon Drop $8.59

    Butter shortbread cookie with lemon mousse and lemon candy on blueberry ice cream

  • Blueberry Cobbler $8.59

    Blueberry Ice Cream with a layer of our house-made Vanilla Mousse on two Graham Cracker Shortbread Cookies

  • Pecan Pie $8.59

    The original Peace Pie is our Pecan Pie; made with the family's homemade Pecan Pie filling recipe, over Vanilla Ice Cream sandwiched between two of our delicious Butter Shortbread Cookies

  • Bananas Foster $8.59

    Our House-made Caramel with Vanilla Mousse and Banana Ice Cream sandwiched between two Cinnamon Cookies

  • Chocolate Covered Strawberry $8.59

    Chocolate Cookie, Chocolate Chips, Chocolate Mousse, Strawberry Ice Cream

  • PB Pretzel $8.59

    Peanut Butter Ice cream with our signature house-made Caramel over a pretzel and sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies

  • Banana Split $8.59

    Banana Ice Cream with Cherry Pie Filling and Chocolate Mousse on two Butter Shortbread Cookies

  • Chocolate Mint $8.59

    Chocolate shortbread cookie with chocolate mousse and mint chip ice cream.

  • Cherry Pie $8.59

    Vanilla Ice cream topped with a layer of Cherry Pie and Vanilla Mousse on two Butter Shortbread Cookies

  • Cookie Dough $8.59

    One of our most popular! Experience Cookie Dough and Ice Cream like you've never had it before. Two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies, layered with Creamy Chocolate Mousse with house-made cookie dough bites swirled on top of Vanilla Ice Cream.

  • Cookies ’N Cream $8.59

    Our take on the Classic Ice Cream Sandwich, Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate & Vanilla Mousse on Chocolate Shortbread Cookies

  • Triple Chocolate Brownie $8.59

    For the True Chocolate Lover: Chocolate Ice Cream, Chocolate Mousse, House-made Brownies, sandwiched between two Chocolate Shortbread Cookies

Peace Pie Details

  • Service options

  • Delivery
  • In-store pickup
  • In-store shopping
  • Onsite services
  • Takeout
  • Popular for

  • Solo dining
  • Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Dining options

  • Table service
  • Amenities

  • Restroom
  • Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Trendy
  • Planning

  • Quick visit
  • Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Children

  • Good for kids

Peace Pie Photos

Peace Pie Picture 1Peace Pie Picture 2Peace Pie Picture 3Peace Pie Picture 4Peace Pie Picture 5Peace Pie Picture 6Peace Pie Picture 7Peace Pie Picture 8Peace Pie Picture 9Peace Pie Picture 10

Peace Pie Location

Peace Pie

326 Carpenters Ln, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

Peace Pie Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 305 user reviews.

ice cream sandwichescookieflavorspeanut buttercaramelselectionfillingkey limepumpkincoffee

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

  • Uncle Charleys Ice CreamUncle Charleys Ice Cream4.0 (250 reviews)

    306 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Ben & Jerry'sBen & Jerry's4.0 (220 reviews)

    414 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Kings Ice Cream ParlourKings Ice Cream Parlour4.0 (107 reviews)

    401 Lafayette St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Kohr Brothers Frozen CustardKohr Brothers Frozen Custard4.0 (341 reviews)

    512 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Fine Fellows CreameryFine Fellows Creamery4.0 (239 reviews)

    313 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Cione GelatoCione Gelato4.0 (85 reviews)

    315 Ocean St #10, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen CustardRita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard4.0 (71 reviews)

    707 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Kohr Brothers Frozen CustardKohr Brothers Frozen Custard4.0 (27 reviews)

    722 Beach Ave APT 1, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Philadelphia Water IcePhiladelphia Water Ice3.0 (6 reviews)

    100 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Scoops on SunsetScoops on Sunset4.0 (110 reviews)

    102 Sunset Blvd, West Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Dry Dock Ice Cream Bar & GrillDry Dock Ice Cream Bar & Grill4.0 (410 reviews)

    1440 Texas Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen CustardRita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard3.0 (7 reviews)

    Shopping Center, 3860 Bayshore Rd North, North Cape May, NJ 08204, USA

  • Categories

    Top Visited Sites

    Top Searches

    Trending Sweet Scoops Posts