Pistol Pete's

For families and visitors enjoying a stay at the Wilderness Resort in Baraboo, Wisconsin, Pistol Pete's offers a highly convenient and popular option for satisfying a sweet tooth. Located directly within the resort, this ice cream spot is a go-to for guests seeking a refreshing treat without having to leave the premises. While it may not be a traditional standalone storefront, its presence within the Wilderness Resort makes it an integral part of the vacation experience for many. Pistol Pete's proudly serves Cedar Crest® Ice Cream, a well-known Wisconsin brand, and offers a variety of creative, hand-mixed creations. Its appeal lies in this combination of a beloved local product with the convenience of being on-site, making it a perfect spot for a quick dessert between water park visits or a late-night craving.

Pistol Pete's is celebrated for its ability to provide a great ice cream experience in a fast-paced environment. As one customer noted, the convenience of having a spot like this inside the Wilderness Resort is a major plus, and for them, the experience was "totally worth it." The lines, despite the business's popularity, tend to move quickly, which is a significant advantage for families who don't want to spend their precious vacation time waiting. The staff, according to a positive review, is also "super nice," contributing to an overall great experience. The variety of menu items, from classic scoops to creative shakes and sundaes, ensures that everyone in the family can find something they love. This focus on efficiency, convenience, and friendly service is what makes Pistol Pete's a cherished part of the Wilderness Resort experience.

However, as with many businesses located within a resort or tourist destination, the pricing and consistency can be points of discussion. A customer review highlighted the high cost, stating that the ice cream was "overpriced because of the convenience of being on-site" and that for a cup of ice cream and a shake, the total was "right around $20." This reflects the reality of pricing in a resort setting, where the added convenience often comes with a higher price tag. The same review also noted some inconsistency in how different employees prepared the ice cream, with some appearing to create a "Coldstone-like" experience while others simply added toppings on top. While this may be a point of frustration for some, it's a detail that many visitors overlook for the sheer convenience of a quick, sweet treat just steps away from their hotel room or water park entrance. The fact that the ice cream "tastes great" and is made with a high-quality local brand like Cedar Crest® helps to justify the visit for many patrons.

Pistol Pete's is located inside the Wilderness Resort in Baraboo, WI 53913, USA. Specifically, it can be found on the second level of Dodge 'Em City in the Wild West region of the resort. As an on-site amenity, its primary audience is resort guests. This location makes it incredibly convenient for anyone staying at the Wilderness Resort who wants a quick and easy dessert.

The accessibility of Pistol Pete's is defined by its position within the resort's sprawling complex. While it may be challenging for a non-guest to find, as one review noted, for those staying at the Wilderness, it's an easy walk from their hotel room or a quick stop while enjoying the resort's many attractions. The convenience of not having to leave the resort property is a major draw and a primary reason for its popularity among guests.

Pistol Pete's offers a menu centered around Cedar Crest® Ice Cream, providing a variety of classic and creative frozen treats.

• Hand-Mixed Creations: The signature offering, where customers can choose their favorite flavors and toppings to be mixed on a frozen slab. The menu features creations with names like "Berry Blast," "Turtle Brownie Sundae Explosion," and "Pistol Pete's Candy Shoot Out."
• Classic Scoops: Customers can also get traditional scoops of Cedar Crest® ice cream in a cup or a waffle cone, including a chocolate-dipped waffle cone.
• Shakes, Malts, and Floats: The menu includes classic shakes and malts in flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry. They also offer floats with Coca-Cola®, Root Beer, or Orange soda.
• Slush Puppies: For a non-ice cream option, Pistol Pete's offers Slush Puppies in a variety of flavors, such as Blue Raspberry and Cherry.
• Other Treats: The menu also lists items like Banana Splits and Ice Cream Sandwiches.

Pistol Pete's has several key features that make it a popular spot within the Wilderness Resort.

• Incredibly Convenient Location: Its placement directly inside the Wilderness Resort is its most significant feature, offering a quick and easy dessert option for guests.
• High-Quality Ice Cream: The use of Wisconsin's own Cedar Crest® Ice Cream ensures a high-quality and delicious product that customers appreciate.
• Fast Service: Despite the frequent crowds, the lines are noted to move quickly, allowing guests to get their treats without a long wait.
• Variety of Options: The menu provides a wide range of choices, from traditional scoops to hand-mixed sundaes and creative shakes, catering to diverse tastes.
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: As part of a family-focused resort, the shop provides a fun and welcoming environment for all ages.

To get in touch with or find Pistol Pete's, here is the contact information for the Wilderness Resort:

Address: Baraboo, WI 53913, USA

While a direct phone number for Pistol Pete's is not readily available, the Wilderness Resort's main number can be used for general inquiries: (608) 253-9729.

For the people of Baraboo and the surrounding communities, Pistol Pete's is a unique local ice cream spot primarily because it provides an excellent dessert option within a major local attraction. While its on-site location means its primary audience is resort guests, it is a key part of the local tourism economy that many residents are proud of. For families in the area who enjoy a staycation or a day at the resort, Pistol Pete's offers a high-quality treat with a local flair, thanks to its use of Cedar Crest® Ice Cream. The convenience of its location, the speed of its service, and the variety of its menu make it a perfectly suited option for a quick, delicious dessert during a fun-filled day. While some may find the pricing higher than a traditional ice cream parlor, the value of the convenience and the quality of the product make it a worthwhile indulgence. Overall, Pistol Pete's is a fun and delicious part of the Wilderness Resort experience that locals can appreciate for its convenience and its contribution to the area's reputation as a top family destination.

Pistol Pete's

Baraboo, WI 53913, USA