Pros & Cones

Welcome to Pros & Cones, Mamaroneck's cherished destination for handcrafted ice cream that's more than just a treat—it's an experience. Nestled in the heart of Mamaroneck, NY, this local gem has quickly become a go-to spot for families, friends, and anyone with a sweet tooth looking for quality and creativity in every scoop. With a friendly and welcoming atmosphere, Pros & Cones stands out not just for its delicious offerings but for its commitment to serving the community with a smile. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, a visit to this shop promises a delightful break from the everyday.

At Pros & Cones, the mission is simple: to provide an unforgettable ice cream experience through a variety of unique and classic flavors, all made with care. The shop takes pride in its innovative approach to traditional desserts, blending well-loved favorites with exciting new combinations. It's a place where you can find everything from a rich, creamy chocolate to adventurous flavors like ricotta cream cheese with fig or earl gray. This dedication to variety ensures there's always something new to discover, making each visit a unique culinary journey.

The shop's commitment to quality is evident in every detail, from the ingredients used to the service provided. The staff are known for being incredibly patient and knowledgeable, happily guiding customers through their flavor choices and even researching allergens to ensure everyone can enjoy a treat safely. This level of personalized service is a cornerstone of the Pros & Cones experience, reinforcing its status as a community hub where everyone feels welcome. It's a place where the simple act of getting ice cream becomes a moment of joy and connection.

Beyond the ice cream itself, Pros & Cones has cultivated a cozy and inviting space. While the shop is modest in size, it offers a comfortable spot to sit and enjoy your dessert. The atmosphere is casual and relaxed, perfect for a quick stop or a longer hang-out session with friends or a date. For families, the shop even offers a fun, free video game, which adds an extra layer of entertainment for younger visitors. The combination of great food, a friendly environment, and thoughtful amenities makes Pros & Cones a complete package for a perfect outing.

For those who appreciate locally-owned businesses, Pros & Cones represents the best of what a small shop can offer. It’s a place built on passion and a genuine desire to serve the community. The enthusiastic reception from local customers since its grand opening is a testament to its quality and charm. The shop's convenient location and warm ambiance have cemented its role as a beloved fixture in the Mamaroneck landscape.

Pros & Cones is conveniently situated at 410 Mamaroneck Ave, a prime spot that’s easy to find and access. Its location right off the Metro-North station makes it an ideal stop for commuters heading home or for anyone exploring the area. Whether you're arriving by train, car, or on foot, getting to this delightful ice cream shop is a breeze. The central location in Mamaroneck's vibrant downtown area means it’s also within walking distance of many other shops and local attractions, making it the perfect final stop after a day of shopping or dining. The ease of access is a significant pro for anyone looking to quickly grab a treat without a hassle.

Parking in the area is generally accessible, with street parking available nearby, so a visit is a straightforward affair. For those utilizing public transportation, the proximity to the Metro-North station cannot be overstated. It ensures that delicious, handcrafted ice cream is never more than a short walk away. This accessibility makes Pros & Cones a fantastic destination for both spontaneous stops and planned outings. The welcoming exterior and inviting signage make it easy to spot, even from a distance, drawing you in with the promise of a sweet treat.

The interior of the shop, while cozy, is well-maintained and clean. The small seating area, complete with a few cafe tables, provides a nice spot to relax and savor your ice cream without feeling rushed. It's a space that feels personal and cared for, adding to the overall charm of the experience. The clean and well-kept bathroom is another thoughtful detail that adds to the comfort and convenience of the shop, a small but important feature that customers often appreciate. The overall design and layout are intended to make you feel right at home.

This central and accessible location makes Pros & Cones a hub for local activity. It’s a great meeting point before or after a movie, a perfect spot for a first date, or a destination for a family outing. The convenience and friendly environment combine to create a place that is more than just a shop—it's a community gathering spot. The shop's location plays a huge role in its appeal, making it a natural choice for anyone in the Mamaroneck area looking for quality ice cream without a long journey.

• Wide Range of Flavors: Pros & Cones offers a diverse selection of ice cream flavors that cater to every taste. From timeless classics like coffee ice cream to more adventurous and unique options such as ricotta cream cheese with fig, tiramisu, and earl gray, there is always something new to try. This variety ensures that both traditionalists and those looking for an exciting new flavor can find exactly what they’re looking for.

• Allergy-Friendly Options: The staff at Pros & Cones are highly trained and committed to helping customers with dietary restrictions. They can research allergens in each flavor to ensure that everyone can enjoy a scoop safely. This attention to detail and commitment to customer safety makes the shop a welcoming place for people with various dietary needs.

• Patience and Excellent Service: The staff is known for being incredibly patient and friendly. They are happy to let customers sample a variety of flavors before making a final decision. This relaxed and pressure-free environment adds to the overall positive experience, making customers feel valued and well-cared for.

• Dairy-Free Options: To accommodate a wider range of customers, Pros & Cones frequently offers dairy-free flavors. This inclusion ensures that those with lactose intolerance or those following a vegan diet can also partake in the delicious treats, making the shop more inclusive and appealing to a broader audience.

• Handcrafted and Unique Flavors: Pros & Cones is celebrated for its inventive and delicious ice cream. Flavors like the ricotta cream cheese with fig showcase a creative approach to dessert that you won’t find at a standard ice cream chain. These unique offerings set the shop apart and make it a destination for foodies and ice cream lovers alike.

• Community-Oriented Atmosphere: Since its grand opening, the shop has fostered a warm, cute, and welcoming environment. It’s a place where locals feel comfortable gathering, whether for a quick scoop or a relaxed date. The cozy interior and friendly staff create a sense of community that makes it a true neighborhood hub.

• Convenient Location: The shop's prime location right off the Metro-North station makes it incredibly accessible for both locals and visitors. This convenience is a significant advantage, ensuring that a great ice cream experience is never far away.

• Family-Friendly Amenities: With a free video game available for kids, Pros & Cones has thoughtful features that make it a great spot for families. This small detail provides entertainment for children, allowing parents to enjoy their treat in a more relaxed manner.

• Impeccably Clean Facilities: Customers frequently note the cleanliness of the shop, including the bathroom. A clean environment contributes significantly to a positive dining experience, and Pros & Cones excels in this regard, showing a high level of care for its patrons.

Address: 410 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA

Phone: (914) 315-1839

Pros & Cones stands as more than just a place to get ice cream; it’s a vital part of the Mamaroneck community. Its blend of exceptional, handcrafted flavors, a welcoming atmosphere, and a commitment to great customer service makes it a perfect fit for locals. Whether you’re looking for a special treat to end a long day, a convenient place to meet up with friends, or a family-friendly spot to make memories, this shop has it all. The dedication to quality and the personal touch from the staff create an experience that feels both unique and familiar. For anyone in the New York area, particularly in Westchester County, Pros & Cones is a must-visit destination that embodies the best of local business charm and deliciousness.

Pros & Cones

410 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA