Pufferbelly's Ice Cream Station

Welcome to Pufferbelly's Ice Cream Station, a true gem in the heart of Fairmont, West Virginia. For us Mountaineers, finding a local spot that consistently delivers both savory meals and sweet treats is a real treasure, and Pufferbelly's certainly fits the bill. This beloved establishment is far more than just an ice cream shop; it's a full-fledged dining experience where you can enjoy everything from hearty soups and delicious paninis to their famous hand-dipped ice cream. Locals rave about the superb and friendly service, the generous portions, and the good prices, making it a go-to for family dinners, quick lunches, or a delightful dessert outing. With a welcoming atmosphere and options for both indoor and outdoor dining, Pufferbelly's Ice Cream Station truly offers something for everyone, cementing its place as a cherished community staple here in West Virginia.

Pufferbelly's Ice Cream Station boasts a highly convenient and accessible location for anyone in the Fairmont, West Virginia area. You'll find this popular eatery and ice cream parlor at 1024 Fairmont Ave, Fairmont, WV 26554, USA. This address places it on a main thoroughfare in Fairmont, making it incredibly easy to find whether you're a local resident running errands or a visitor passing through our beautiful state. Its prominent position on Fairmont Avenue ensures that it's visible and straightforward to navigate to, reducing any hassle in finding your destination. While specific parking details aren't explicitly provided, being on a major road in a local community typically means there are accessible parking options nearby. The ease of access, combined with its reputation for quality food and ice cream, makes Pufferbelly's a convenient and appealing stop for a meal or a sweet treat any day of the week, solidifying its role as a true community hub in Fairmont.

Pufferbelly's Ice Cream Station offers a surprisingly extensive menu that goes well beyond just ice cream, catering to a wide range of tastes for both meals and desserts. Their commitment to variety ensures there's something for every member of the family.

• Hand-Dipped Ice Cream: At its heart, Pufferbelly's is an ice cream station, offering a "nice little selection" of hand-dipped ice cream flavors. These come in cones and cups of various sizes, with options for waffle cones and waffle bowls. They also offer "dipped or rolled" cones with various choices.
• Specialty Sundaes: Their sundae menu is robust and creative, featuring unique names and delicious combinations such as "Moose Tracks," "Dirt Diggin'," "Strawberry Shortcake," "Hot Fudge," "Chocolate Lover," "Scotcharoo," "Turtle," "S'mores," "GrassHopper," "Fluffer Nutter," "Hot Cobbler," "Carmel Nut Sunday," "Banana Split," "German Chocolate," "Brownie," "Hot Belgian Waffle," "Train Wreck," and "Hound Hog." They also have a signature "The Pufferbelly" sundae.
• "Explosions" (Blended Treats): Pufferbelly's offers "Explosions," which are blended ice cream treats similar to blizzards, with various mix-in flavors like "Butter Pecan," "Red Velvet Cheesecake," "Strawberry Salted Caramel," "Cookies-n-Cream," and more. Customers can also "Create your Own Explosion" by mixing two favorite toppings.
• Milkshakes and Malts: A variety of milkshakes and malts are available in regular and large sizes, with classic flavors like Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, and Peanut Butter, along with more unique options such as Pumpkin and Cake Batter.
• Savory Food Menu: Pufferbelly's also boasts a full food menu. This includes:
  • Appetizers: Such as "Large Ribbon Fries," "Freight Car Fries" (loaded with green onions, bacon, jalapeños, and nacho cheese), "Box Car Willie Nachos," "Chicken Tender Basket," "Cheese Sticks," "Fried Pickle Chips," and "Fried Green Tomatoes."
  • Soups: Including "Union Station Vegetable Soup," "Chain Gang Chili," "Chicken Noodle," "Soup of the Day," and "Soup Beans and Cornbread." Reviewers specifically praise their "great soups" like "Broccoli and cheese soup."
  • Salads: A wide selection like "Railyard Salad," "Sidetrack," "Super Chief (Chef Salad)," "Short Line (Spinach Salad)," "Casey Jones (Caesar Salad)," "New! Crab Cake Salad," "Depot (House Salad)," and "Gateway (Greek Salad)." The "greek salad" is noted as "solid."
  • Wraps & Paninis: Options like "Tygart Valley Flyer" (grilled chicken), "Ches-c" (chicken, bacon, ranch), "Deadheader Buffalo Chicken," "Derailer" (shaved steak), "Scalehouse" (salmon), "Tom Thumb" (vegetarian), and quesadillas. The "buffalo chicken panini" is described as "very tasty."
  • Burgers and Sandwiches: Including various burgers like BBQ Bacon Burger and Classic Burger, and sandwiches such as "Railroad Reuben," "Hobo Hoagie," "Trestle Fish," and "Caboose Club."
• Craft Sodas and Candies: Beyond their main food and ice cream, they also offer "craft sodas" (including Boylan sodas), "Albanese candies," and other "sweet treats" like chocolate-covered fruits and Pez.

Pufferbelly's Ice Cream Station stands out with several key features and highlights that make it a beloved destination for both food and frozen treats in Fairmont, West Virginia. These attributes contribute significantly to its strong reputation and loyal customer base.

• Dual Appeal: Food and Ice Cream: A primary highlight is its successful combination of a full-service food menu with a dedicated ice cream parlor. Customers praise both aspects, noting "Good food and great ice cream." This dual offering makes it a versatile spot for a complete meal or just a dessert.
• Delicious Savory Options: Beyond the ice cream, their savory menu receives high marks. Reviews mention "Great soups," "good portions," and "good prices" for items like "broccoli and cheese soup" and "greek salad." The "buffalo chicken panini" is also specifically highlighted as "very tasty," and homemade chips are a hit.
• Hand-Dipped Ice Cream Selection: For ice cream lovers, their "nice little selection" of hand-dipped ice cream is a major draw. They promise to deliver "the finest, premium ice cream" with "as many flavors, variations, and options as we can write on our board," offering a wide range of sundaes and "Explosions" (blended treats).
• Superb and Friendly Service: The staff at Pufferbelly's consistently receives accolades for being "superb and friendly." This excellent customer service enhances the overall dining experience, making patrons feel welcomed and valued.
• Generous Portions and Good Prices: Customers frequently comment on the "good portions" and "good prices," indicating that Pufferbelly's offers great value for money. This affordability combined with satisfying serving sizes is a significant plus for families and individuals.
• Indoor and Outdoor Dining: The availability of "outdoor dining as well," alongside indoor seating, is a notable feature. This provides flexibility for customers, allowing them to choose their preferred dining environment, especially appealing during pleasant weather.
• Extensive Menu Variety: Pufferbelly's prides itself on a "great selection" with "lots of options," making it "hard to choose because it’s all good." This diverse menu, from appetizers and salads to sandwiches and specialized ice cream creations, ensures there's something for everyone.
• Online Menu Availability: The ability to "read their menu online ahead of time" is a convenient feature that enhances the customer experience, allowing patrons to plan their order and explore the extensive options before arriving.
• Nostalgic and Railroad-Themed Decor: While not explicitly stated in all reviews, the name "Pufferbelly's Ice Cream Station" and the overall branding suggest a charming railroad theme, which often contributes to a unique and family-friendly atmosphere.

For those eager to visit or get in touch with Pufferbelly's Ice Cream Station, here is their contact information:

Address: 1024 Fairmont Ave, Fairmont, WV 26554, USA

Phone: (304) 363-3221

Pufferbelly's Ice Cream Station is an exceptionally suitable destination for locals in the West Virginia region, particularly those in Fairmont and surrounding communities, for a multitude of compelling reasons. Firstly, its unique appeal as both a full-service eatery and an ice cream parlor makes it incredibly versatile. For us West Virginians, finding a single spot where you can enjoy a hearty meal—be it a "tasty" buffalo chicken panini, a "solid" Greek salad, or comforting "broccoli and cheese soup"—and then indulge in delicious hand-dipped ice cream and sundaes, is a significant advantage. This dual offering caters to all cravings, from savory to sweet, simplifying dining decisions for families and groups.

The consistent praise for "superb and friendly" service truly sets Pufferbelly's apart. A welcoming and attentive staff enhances the entire dining experience, making customers feel valued and encouraging repeat visits. This commitment to excellent customer service fosters a strong sense of community, making it a place where locals feel comfortable and appreciated. Coupled with "good portions" and "good prices," Pufferbelly's offers outstanding value, which is always a key consideration for families and regular patrons in our communities.

Furthermore, its convenient location on Fairmont Avenue ensures easy accessibility for residents, whether they're coming from work, running errands, or simply looking for a pleasant outing. The availability of both indoor and outdoor dining provides flexibility, allowing patrons to enjoy their meals and treats in their preferred setting, especially during pleasant weather. The extensive menu, which can be viewed online, also adds to the convenience, enabling customers to explore the "great selection" and make informed choices before even arriving.

In conclusion, Pufferbelly's Ice Cream Station is more than just an ice cream shop or a restaurant; it’s a vital and cherished part of the Fairmont community. Its blend of diverse, high-quality food options, premium ice cream, excellent service, and great value makes it an ideal choice for locals seeking a consistently satisfying dining experience. It truly embodies the spirit of a beloved neighborhood establishment that caters to the diverse tastes and needs of West Virginians, ensuring that everyone leaves happy and well-fed.

Pufferbelly's Ice Cream Station

1024 Fairmont Ave, Fairmont, WV 26554, USA