Sundaes on Sylvan Introduce
For those in Rome City and the surrounding areas of Noble County, Sundaes on Sylvan is more than just an ice cream shop—it's a community gathering place that perfectly captures the essence of a lakeside summer. This charming, seasonal eatery is a favorite among locals and a discovery for visitors, offering a delightful escape with a focus on simple pleasures. The atmosphere is relaxed and friendly, making it a perfect stop after a day on Sylvan Lake or a family outing. From the delicious, cool treats to the warm and welcoming staff, every element is designed to create a memorable experience.
The core of Sundaes on Sylvan’s appeal is its commitment to providing great ice cream in a fantastic setting. It’s a place where families, friends, and even their four-legged companions can come together to enjoy a sweet treat. The shop is deeply rooted in the local community, serving as a hub for both residents and visitors who are drawn to its friendly vibe and high-quality offerings. The team is known for going above and beyond to ensure a positive experience for every customer. This dedication to excellent service is a major reason why Sundaes on Sylvan has become a cherished part of the Rome City experience, earning rave reviews and a loyal following that eagerly awaits its seasonal opening each year.
Sundaes on Sylvan is ideally situated at 253 Kelly St in Rome City, Indiana. This location, nestled on the shores of beautiful Sylvan Lake, provides a picturesque backdrop for enjoying a cone or a sundae. Its accessibility is a significant draw, making it an easy destination for anyone in the area. The shop is not only accessible by car but also from the boat ramp, which is a unique feature that caters to those enjoying a day on the lake. The proximity to the water enhances the overall experience, allowing patrons to enjoy their treats with a scenic view. The shop's convenient placement makes it a go-to spot for locals and a great find for tourists visiting the area's natural attractions.
While the location is a major plus, it is important for visitors to be aware of the walking areas. As noted in a customer review, some of the walkways can be a bit rickety, which may be a concern for individuals with mobility challenges. However, the overall visit is consistently described as "very nice," and the scenic beauty of the location more than makes up for this minor inconvenience. The shop's charm is undeniably linked to its rustic, lakeside feel, which includes the rustic nature of its physical location.
Sundaes on Sylvan offers a range of services centered around a fantastic ice cream experience, but they also have some unique offerings that set them apart.
- Classic Ice Cream Treats: The menu features a variety of premium ice cream flavors, with customer reviews noting the "very good ice cream" and a wide selection of flavors, toppings, and serving styles. Whether you prefer a simple cone, a decadent sundae, or a milkshake, they have something for every craving.
- Pup Cups: A major highlight for dog owners, the shop is famously dog-friendly and offers "pup cups" for their canine visitors. This thoughtful service makes Sundaes on Sylvan a welcoming spot for the entire family, pets included, as noted by a delighted out-of-town visitor.
- Specialty Food Items: While primarily an ice cream shop, the menu may also feature a variety of other items, ensuring that customers have a complete range of options for a satisfying meal or snack. However, the ice cream remains the star attraction, as mentioned in customer reviews and local praise.
- Seasonal Availability: As a seasonal establishment, Sundaes on Sylvan is a cherished part of the Rome City summer. Locals eagerly anticipate its opening, and its limited operating season makes every visit feel like a special event.
Several key features and highlights make Sundaes on Sylvan a standout destination in Rome City. These are the elements that create a loyal customer base and a positive reputation.
- Outstanding Staff: The staff's "absolutely marvelous" service is a recurring theme in customer reviews. They are known for being welcoming and friendly, creating a pleasant and inviting atmosphere for everyone who visits. This level of customer care is a significant reason for its popularity.
- Dog-Friendly Environment: The shop’s welcoming attitude towards dogs, complete with complimentary pup cups, makes it a top choice for pet owners. This inclusivity ensures that no family member is left out of the fun, turning a simple ice cream run into a true family affair.
- Lakeside Charm: The location on the shores of Sylvan Lake, with a back porch that offers beautiful views, is a huge draw. It provides a serene and scenic setting that elevates the ice cream experience from a simple treat to a relaxing moment in nature.
- Community Hub: Sundaes on Sylvan functions as a central meeting place for the community. It’s a place where you're likely to run into neighbors and friends, fostering a strong sense of local connection and community spirit.
For those who wish to visit this local favorite, here is the essential contact and location information.
Address: 253 Kelly St, Rome City, IN 46784, USA
Phone: (260) 502-1688
Sundaes on Sylvan is the perfect place for locals because it embodies the best of what Rome City has to offer: community spirit, beautiful natural scenery, and a commitment to quality. The friendly staff and dog-friendly policies make it an inclusive and welcoming space for the entire family. Its seasonal nature adds to its allure, making it a beloved tradition for many residents. While visitors should be mindful of the rustic walkways, the excellent ice cream and a chance to relax by the lake make it a worthwhile trip. For anyone in the area looking for a sweet treat and a moment of peace, Sundaes on Sylvan is a cherished local gem that consistently delivers a fantastic experience, making it a must-visit spot for both residents and visitors alike.
Sundaes on Sylvan Ice Cream
Ice Cream Flavors
- Blue Ribbon Chocolate
- Birthday Cake Celebration
- Dark Chocolate Pb Wave
- Chocolate Moose Tracks
- Mint Chip
- Strawberry
- Sorta Sweet, Sorta Beth Dutton
- Java Chip
- Vanilla
- Lemon Poppy-Seed Cake
- Mixed Berry Madness
- Supercow
- Swirl Twix-A-Lot
- Peanut Butter Cookie Dough
- Cookies And Cream
- Cookie Monster
- Sea Monster
- Cookie Dough
- Strawberry Cheesecake
Sundaes on Sylvan Details
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- Delivery
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Payments
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Sundaes on Sylvan Photos










Sundaes on Sylvan Location
Sundaes on Sylvan Reviews
flavorspricescutesummerareabutterbeercaramelshake
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1We were visiting from out of town and had to by local, and nothing better than Ice Cream. The ice cream was great, the staff was absolutely marvelous, they welcomed our dog and she even got a pup cup. We will definitely make this place a must visit every time we come to visit family.
June 30 · Mirely TorregrosaIt was very good ice cream, but the walkways were a bit rickety. Especially for someone who is disabled. One of the ramp areas was particularly scary. Otherwise very nice visit.
July 10 · Randy GibsonI love all the choices they have. Today I got banana moose tracks! So good
July 04 · Roberta StoneExcellent little ice cream place! Take it out back and enjoy the lake view! A single scoop is very generous. Butter beer with caramel swirl, YUM!!
August 02 · Sandra Robben-Weber6/30/24 stopped in with a buddy to get some ice cream. I ordered the vanilla shake. Shake tasted terrible. Had an off putting flavor. 1 out of 10 Would not recommend.
June 30 · Seth Peterson
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

3204 E County Rd 900 N, Rome City, IN 46784, USA

1405 W 700 S, Wolcottville, IN 46795, USA

118 E Main St, Albion, IN 46701, USA

955 S 00 Ew, LaGrange, IN 46761, USA

113 S Cavin St, Ligonier, IN 46767, USA

5975 US-20, LaGrange, IN 46761, USA

11925 W 700 S, Millersburg, IN 46543, USA

4504 IN-327, Garrett, IN 46738, USA

401 Defiance St, Howe, IN 46746, USA

800 S Van Buren St, Shipshewana, IN 46565, USA

655 S Van Buren St, Shipshewana, IN 46565, USA

241 E Farver St, Shipshewana, IN 46565, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





