The Maplery Ice Cream Introduce
The Maplery Ice Cream is a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Varysburg, New York, offering a sweet escape for locals and visitors alike. This charming outdoor-only ice cream shop has quickly become a beloved spot, renowned not only for its extensive and creative menu but also for its exceptionally friendly atmosphere. Located conveniently on US-20A, it's the perfect destination to satisfy your sweet tooth and enjoy a moment of tranquility in the fresh country air. The owners have cultivated a warm and welcoming environment that makes every visit a pleasant experience, whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through. They've built a reputation for genuine hospitality, with customers frequently praising the friendly and approachable nature of the staff. This dedication to creating a positive experience is a significant part of what makes The Maplery Ice Cream a standout establishment in the community. It’s more than just a place to get dessert; it’s a place to feel at home.
The shop's commitment to quality is evident in every scoop. They offer a diverse range of flavors that cater to all palates, from traditional classics that evoke a sense of nostalgia to innovative and exciting new creations. A particular highlight is their use of local ingredients, including their very own Boxler Maple Syrup, which adds a unique and authentic regional flavor to their offerings. This local connection not only supports other businesses but also ensures a freshness and quality you can taste. For those looking for something a bit more adventurous, The Maplery Ice Cream features a unique "Barlor" collection of boozy, alcohol-infused ice creams, a popular option for adults seeking a novel treat. The variety and quality of their menu demonstrate a passion for crafting delicious desserts that stand out from the ordinary. The emphasis on locally sourced ingredients and a wide range of options, from family-friendly classics to adult-only specialties, solidifies The Maplery Ice Cream's reputation as a top-tier destination for frozen treats.
---
Situated at 2369 US-20A in Varysburg, New York, The Maplery Ice Cream is easily accessible for anyone traveling through the region. The shop's location on a main route makes it a convenient stop for locals running errands or for families enjoying a scenic drive through Wyoming County. The outdoor-only nature of the venue means it's a perfect place to pull over, stretch your legs, and enjoy a treat in the open air. There is ample parking available, making it simple to stop by without the hassle of searching for a spot. While the establishment itself is an outdoor space, the friendly and accommodating staff are always ready to assist customers with any needs they may have. The welcoming layout and natural surroundings make for a stress-free and enjoyable visit every time. Its prime location not only makes it easy to find but also positions it as a perfect landmark for meeting up with friends or family. The rural setting adds to its charm, providing a peaceful backdrop for enjoying your ice cream.
The accessibility extends beyond its physical location. The Maplery Ice Cream fosters a community feel that makes everyone feel welcome. The focus on an outdoor experience encourages a laid-back and casual atmosphere, perfect for a sunny day. This simple, yet effective, approach to creating a comfortable space ensures that the shop is not just a point on a map but a true destination. The ease of access, combined with a friendly environment, makes it a go-to spot for a quick break or a planned outing. Whether you're coming from nearby towns or from further afield, getting to The Maplery Ice Cream is a breeze, and the experience is well worth the trip. The straightforward location on US-20A acts as a beacon for those in search of a delicious and memorable ice cream experience.
---
The Maplery Ice Cream provides a variety of delicious treats and a high-quality experience for all who visit.
Traditional Ice Cream: Enjoy a wide selection of classic and unique ice cream flavors served in cones, cups, or bowls.
Alcoholic "Barlor" Ice Cream: A special menu of boozy ice cream flavors, perfect for adults looking for a fun and sophisticated twist on a classic dessert. These unique offerings set The Maplery apart from other local shops.
Milkshakes: Thick, creamy, and made to order, their milkshakes are a popular choice for those who prefer their ice cream in a drinkable form. They can be customized with various flavors.
Sundaes: Indulge in classic sundaes piled high with toppings like hot fudge, whipped cream, and cherries, or create your own masterpiece.
Ice Cream Flights: A great option for the indecisive or adventurous, these flights allow you to sample multiple flavors in one sitting. It's a fantastic way to explore the full range of what the shop has to offer without committing to a single scoop.
Waffle Cones: Freshly made, flavorful waffle cones provide the perfect vessel for any scoop, adding a delightful crunch and extra flavor to your treat.
Maple Syrup Products: Given its name, The Maplery also features products made with their own Boxler Maple Syrup, offering a taste of local craftsmanship beyond just ice cream. This includes ice cream flavors and other unique treats infused with the rich, natural sweetness of real maple syrup.
---
The Maplery Ice Cream distinguishes itself with a few key features that make it a local favorite.
Outdoor-Only Venue: The shop's outdoor-only setup is a defining feature. It encourages customers to enjoy their treats in the fresh air, creating a relaxed and informal atmosphere. This makes it an ideal spot for a pleasant afternoon outing, a summer evening treat, or a casual family get-together. The open-air setting is perfect for enjoying the beautiful Varysburg landscape while savoring a cold dessert.
Unique "Barlor" Collection: A major highlight is the exclusive line of boozy ice cream flavors. This adult-friendly offering provides a sophisticated and unique experience that you won't find at most other ice cream shops. The creative and delicious alcoholic concoctions are a big draw for a mature crowd.
Exceptional Customer Service: According to numerous customer reviews, the owners and staff are consistently described as super nice, welcoming, and friendly. This high level of personal and genuine hospitality enhances the overall experience and is a primary reason why people keep coming back. The warm interactions make every customer feel valued and appreciated.
Locally Sourced Ingredients: The use of authentic Boxler Maple Syrup is a significant highlight. This connection to local agriculture not only supports the community but also ensures a distinctive and high-quality flavor in their maple-infused creations. It’s a testament to their commitment to providing the best possible product.
Creative and Diverse Menu: Beyond the traditional scoops, The Maplery offers a creative range of options, including flavorful waffle cones, milkshakes, sundaes, and even ice cream flights. This variety ensures that there is something for everyone, regardless of their preference. The menu is a testament to their innovative approach to frozen desserts.
---
To get in touch with The Maplery Ice Cream, you can use the following details:
Address: 2369 US-20A, Varysburg, NY 14167, USA
Phone: (716) 776-2753
---
The Maplery Ice Cream is more than just a place to grab a scoop; it’s a vital part of the Varysburg community fabric. For locals, it represents a perfect blend of high-quality products, a welcoming atmosphere, and a genuine commitment to customer satisfaction. The shop's outdoor-only setting provides a natural gathering place where families, friends, and neighbors can come together to enjoy a simple pleasure. The friendly and familiar faces behind the counter, who many customers describe as the owners, make everyone feel like a part of the family. This personal touch is what truly elevates the experience beyond a simple transaction and turns it into a cherished community ritual. The consistent praise for the staff's welcoming nature in customer reviews highlights that the people behind the counter are just as important as the delicious treats they serve.
Furthermore, the business’s dedication to using local ingredients, particularly their own Boxler Maple Syrup, demonstrates a deep-rooted connection to the region. This commitment not only results in exceptional flavors but also strengthens the local economy and fosters a sense of pride in regional products. The diverse menu, from classic favorites to the unique boozy "Barlor" collection, ensures that The Maplery caters to all members of the community, offering something for every age and preference. It’s a place where kids can get a classic chocolate cone and adults can enjoy a more sophisticated, alcohol-infused treat. The Maplery Ice Cream embodies the best of what a local business can be—a place of quality, community, and genuine hospitality. For anyone in and around Varysburg, it's the perfect destination for a delicious and heartwarming treat that feels like home.
The Maplery Ice Cream Food & drink
Traditional Ice Cream
- 1/2 Scoop of Ice Cream $3.75
- 1 Scoop of Ice Cream $4.75
- 2 Scoops of Ice Cream $6.00
- 3 Scoops of Ice Cream $7.50
Boozy Ice Cream (21+)
- 1 Scoop Boozy Ice Cream $8.00
- 2 Scoops Boozy Ice Cream $11.00
- 3 Scoops Boozy Ice Cream $13.00
- Boozy Flight $15.00
Milkshakes
- Regular Milkshake $7.50
Vanilla, Chocolate or Maple
- Large Milkshake $9.00
Vanilla, Chocolate or Maple
- Mixer $7.00
Vanilla or Chocolate custard with your choice of topping mixed in
Sundaes
- Regular Sundae $7.00
- Large Sundae $8.25
- Maple Specialty Sundae $10.00
The Maplery Ice Cream Photos










The Maplery Ice Cream Location
The Maplery Ice Cream Reviews
bourbonflightatmosphere
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1The Maplery Ice Cream in Varysburg is a must-visit! This outdoor-only spot offers a fantastic array of flavors, from classic favorites to creative boozy options! The best part? The owners are super nice and friendly! Their welcoming spirit adds to the charming outdoor atmosphere, making it a perfect place to relax and enjoy your ice cream. If you’re in the area, grab a cone and enjoy the fresh air at this lovely gem! 🍨💖
July 20 · Sarah KiefferIf you're in Varysburg, you need to check out The Maplery Ice Cream. They have a solid range of flavors, especially the boozy ones.It’s an outdoor-only venue, and the owner is a genuinely nice individual, very welcoming and friendly. Perfect place to grab a treat and enjoy the fresh air. Highly recommend!
July 20 · Davis McDonoughI've been here several times, so when my family from out of state came for a visit, I knew they needed to try it. We all got something different, and they all were amazing. The flight of boozy ice cream was a hit with their signature maple bourbon being the best. The service was outstanding, and the owners also talked with us about what other plans they have in store for an event venue. Can't wait to come back.
July 22 · Kathy Redfern⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️A Sweet (and Boozy) Surprise in Varysburg – The Maplery Ice CreamIf you’re ever near Varysburg, NY—or taking a scenic drive near Letchworth State Park—The Maplery Ice Cream is absolutely worth the stop. It’s a cozy, locally owned spot that brings together two of my favorite things: rich maple flavor and a splash of fun in the form of alcoholic ice cream.First off, the atmosphere is charming and welcoming. The staff was friendly, patient with questions, and clearly passionate about their craft. Everything is centered around Boxler maple syrup, which gives their ice cream a warm, authentic sweetness that sets it apart from typical ice cream shops.Now, let’s talk about the alcoholic ice cream—easily the highlight of my visit. I tried a few flavors, and they were fantastic. The bourbon maple pecan was perfectly balanced—not overpowering, just enough kick to make it feel like a grown-up dessert. They serve them in regular cones or even flights (yes, like a beer flight but for boozy ice cream!), which is such a fun idea if you want to sample a few without committing to just one.I also appreciated that they didn’t skimp on creativity—there were unique flavor combinations like rum-raisin maple and a creamy Irish cream swirl. Each one tasted smooth, not icy, and you could tell the quality of ingredients was high.Pro tips:• Go for a flight if it’s your first time—totally worth it.• Pair it with a flavored waffle cone if you want to go all out.• Make it a stop on your way to or from Letchworth—it’s close and makes for the perfect treat after hiking.In short, The Maplery is doing something special with their blend of local flavor and adult indulgence. Whether you’re a maple lover, an ice cream fanatic, or just curious about alcohol-infused desserts—this place is a hidden gem. I’ll definitely be back!
July 22 · Red KidzWe drove an hour for the maplery experience to have unfriendly service. The owners didn’t acknowledge us and walked by several times. Also no restroom to use for customers. Are they not aware of porta potties?
July 20 · Lisa Ehde
More Ice Cream Shops Near Me

4088 Varysburg Rd, Warsaw, NY 14569, USA

11105 Alexander Rd, Attica, NY 14011, USA

3635 Main St, Strykersville, NY 14145, USA

12 Center St, Warsaw, NY 14569, USA

13119 Broadway, Alden, NY 14004, USA

9114 Alleghany Rd, Corfu, NY 14036, USA

79 Elm St, East Aurora, NY 14052, USA

431 Main St, East Aurora, NY 14052, USA

117 Hamburg St, East Aurora, NY 14052, USA

5 N Main St, Perry, NY 14530, USA

3872 W Main Street Rd, Batavia, NY 14020, USA

670 E Main St, Batavia, NY 14020, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Top Searches
Trending Sweet Scoops Posts





